A Certain Scientific Railgun Mafia - Game Over: Rainbow's End [Mafia Victory]

Idk I keep thinking her posts feel real to me
I know that sounds dumb and maybe I’m just confbiased into thinking she’s town but every time I think I should reevaluate her I read her posts again and still conclude that she’s probably town :wowee:
I mean it’s bothering me because it’s definitely an anti-consensus read and I don’t know why I have that read
I’m starting to think my reads don’t actually matter and I should go back to my original plan of identifying a strong town member to sheep
Problem is the people I found as town were not exactly what i would call typical sheepable material
Like I was townreading Eli but under most circumstances I wouldn’t blindly sheep him even if he was locktown because it still says nothing about his read accuracy
I townread lol but had mixed feelings on his reads too
I townread eevee eventually but that was kinda too late, and I don’t think my reads are that dissimilar to the ones he gave anyway
So idk what I’m supposed to do here because it’ll just turn into a waiting game to see when I die

I guess I could just start by not shielding slots anymore

Seems like a dumb move not to defend my reads but I’m probably wrong anyway

I’ll try to do some VCA later in the day but it’s not going to be super fruitful before we get a wolf flip

It’s weird reading her because she’s kind of…like she’s fucking around or more vibing, but is giving the limited amount and that’s really it.

Like kinda feel like if she was a wolf she’d actually be more into changing things into a certain direction, where here she’s just making her own moves and not really caring of what others are saying or doing besides reading them.

That’s kind of my best estimation on her.

Massive chance I’m way off since I can’t read her that well.

1 Like

I’m like…the worst type of player to have in terms of getting things done because you have players that will look at a thing and 90% chance that they scumread it for whatever odd reason that they can come up with.
Meanwhile you have me who reads that same thing and I default to townreading it with reasoning.

Yeah i agree with this tbh

If she’s town who does it point to being a wolf, though? She’s not dead and I highly doubt she was protected, so either some of her reads are wrong or wolves thought enough people would vote her today

In which case it strongly suggests that Seth and Zone are less likely wolves because they could keep the mech crap to themselves and push Night as an easy target, so I guess that’s a read

Like the only thing i would really get out of Night being town is Hippo wolf, but I don’t think it’s guaranteed either. I think it’s highly likely one of them is a wolf but it’s not impossible for them to be T/T. I don’t think they’re W/W so far.

Well let’s take out those 3 right now…

Off the top of my head, you I think are town, Kiiruma I’m assuming is town, Helz based on mech and Kiiruma saying things worked out is town…

That leaves…

Atlas
Gorta
Hippopablompoyeetus
JakeTheWolfe
Whysper

I think Atlas is town
I want to pick Gorta’s brain because while I think his interactions have been towny, his pushes have been wrong
Hippo I said my stuff on already
Whysper I’m undecided on
I’m not jumping to townread Helz yet either
This just defaults Jake to the bottom of my reads (again) and I’m not sure whether that’s a good or bad thing because I have serious issues understanding the motive behind some of the things he’s said in this game, but I’m not locked in the idea that he’s scum either. I just feel like I don’t have a better vote target rn.

1 Like

Same in regards to the ending.

I’ve been thinking Atlas is town throughout my time in this game as well.

Hippo I had the same based on his behavior between his mafia game last game we were together and this game.

Soooo leaving Gorta/Jake/Whysper???

Does that make sense?

Maybe leave a bit of room for Helz if the item thing screws things up and we’re misclearing him?

My problem with this is just that all three of them are kinda LHF
I don’t think that team works without a powerwolf since we’ve had the Jake wagon dissolve or fail to flip twice now
And I think Jake posts the most frequently out of the three of them, and I would not consider him to be a powerwolf lol
So if those three are wolves there has to be a wolf among the players actually steering the thread
And while Hippo/Arc have been saying Night qualifies as a top poster, I don’t actually think anyone besides me has been taking her reads seriously, or at least it didn’t feel that way. So she still wouldn’t qualify as a powerwolf unless her only goal is to try to break up wagons on wolves each day without pushing blatant agenda.

Well the current powerwolf candidates would be…
looks at votecounts
notices you’re at 1,000 posts doubling the next player
The fuck is wrong with you?

Possibly Hippo…?

1 Like

Anyway my conclusion is that the Gorta/Jake/Whysper team doesn’t really seem to me like it would work in any world, except if I am powerwolfing lol
And fmpov I can tell you already that I’m not

1 Like

Wow quoting the vote counts really fucked that up.

1 Like

I could see Jake being a wolf with Whysper based on those vote counts tbh.

Whisper not voting Day 1, then voting Eevee Day 2 as Jake is the counter wagon.

1 Like

Tbf I thought on D1 that Hippo was powerwolfing with a potato team so it’s still a logical possibility

The role claim gets me, though. I do believe he got to add Arctic to a chat, but I don’t know why a wolf would be able to do that unless there are only 3 packwolves to begin with. And tbh I don’t really care about those kinds of assumptions until we’ve successfully yeeted 3 wolves in the thread, and then we can speculate on whether the 4th one is a packwolf or not.

Oh…wait…that’s where the Arctic shit came in? I thought he actually fucked up and thought Atlas was Arctic.

Whysper was trying to get me to stop scumreading Jake on D1 for kinda meh reasons (similar to what isolde said about Jake being wolfy even as a villager) so I already had them as a highly possible team if either of them flip wolf.

No, he claimed within an hour of SoD today that his role allows him to pick a player not in this game and add them to his rolecard or something