April Showers The Third - NIGHT 3 (12/16)

[Marluna]

Even though I don’t agree with his reasoning, he was the first, who had an actual reason, why my vote on Jarek looks bad. (except the one, that I should have known it was a joke)

I think a wolf just would went the already established “it’s a bad vote, cause it’s clearly a meme” argument, if they wanted to shading me, based on that early vote.

[Rhea]

An updated read list:

soweli t
Jarek t
Leafia lt
Willow lt
Kiiruma lt
Canping lt
Marluna lt
Chomps lt
Frostwolf103 n
childe n
Creature n
pandora lw
Heiter lw
Starboy lw

[Jarek]

@Rhea

I don’t agree with this, for the record. A wolf Kiiruma can use that encouragement to change the subject to shunt the conversation in whatever direction he wants, but he did not try to do that. It feels like an opportunity he would have taken.

Eh okay I can see that perspective. Maybe I’m trying to connect something where there isn’t but I felt the read that leafia and kiiruma are paired and leafia was trying to stop leafia from slipping was right, somehow

[Starboy]

@soweli

@Starboy

What do you mean by you “might be placebo’ing”? I have some other thoughts on this post noted down but I would like clarification first, posting them would spoil the read

It means my memory of the event was poor; the only part i distinctly remember was thinking that my reasoning was roughly “i scrolled up and picked the first person who [not sure what my specific criteria was but likely ‘looks bad’” but I don’t know if i actually had any significant reaction towards canping’s post and could have only believed that because in retrospect I was looking for “why did i specifically vote canping over anybody else”

Also I’m not really a big fan of canping’s later postss i stay winning

@Canping

why are some of you nitpicking that it certainly isnt AI only 1 or 2 posts out of my other posts? this is just clutching on straws

too defenseive, ez.

Initially I’d marked this post down as too defensive, but as I was typing this I realized that it’s quite literally a defense, I asked them to explain themselves. I don’t hate it looking at that lens but it still feels a bit weird, notably the second quote tacked onto the end.

[soweli]

sorry for my oddities that surpass the bounds of your comprehension

[Rhea]

Starboy’s lines of questioning feel off and their posts read like somebody trying especially hard to seem like a villager without actually reading like, well, somebody who seems like a villager. This is a red flag to me and I would like to investigate further.

Heiter has spoken several times about non-game-related matters and still has not given a game-related comment despite having two people to do so. This is a place I would like to see pressure.

VOTE: Heiter.

pandora has commented on the game, but its posts seem to lack a “creative spirit” that villagers tend to have: the comments are all rather easy observations to make and do not provide any novel connections or leaps of logic. She has provided mere idle commentary.

Creature’s near-complete absence bothers me, though he did leave an explanation, so I cannot complain too much. I would like to see much more from him when he returns.

childe’s absence also bothers me, but not as much as Creature’s, given that it had a similar issue in my Kakegurui: Compulsive Gambler Mafia. Still, this is no reason to disregard the issue.

I feel I should have better thoughts on Frostwolf103 by now given his volume of content, but I do not. Nothing he has done has seemed especially villagery to me, but I have not been reading nearly as closely as I should. I will read him a bit more closely in a moment.

[Starboy]

@Frostwolf103

So yeah, what’s the pressure bro

This has been true most of the thread, multiple votes placed that don’t do anything. Your votes need a push/reasoning behind them to be worth placing.

[Starboy]

Like most of these points from Jarek,

@Jarek

I appreciate the ideal that we’d like to move on from the smiley discussion however there have been no more attempts to discuss much else, from you or really nobody else. Possibly scummy, situationally depending on how Kiiruma is percieving how the discussion went or more importantly how kiiruma believes certain players were being percieved - to the point he’d have to step in and ask for people to “look elsewhere”. Hm…

but this reads like a bit of a stretch to me. The town, as Jarek had said, had more or less moved on. I find it unlikely that Kiiruma would pop into thread, and attempt to divert away from an already dying disscussion. If anything I think, if Kiiruma is attempting to direct us, would be directing us back onto the disscussion.

[Starboy]

@Jarek

Because they haven’t. It’s been 4~ Hours since their last post and they haven’t actually branched off into another topic. They’ve advocated for shutting down something generating content within the thread and haven’t provided a reason to go anywhere else. If the town decided to listen to kiiruma we would be stagnant and doing not much of anything.

Yeah I’m listening. VOTE: Kiiruma

[Canping]

i see what you mean, but its not only their response and what i did to just to read them as town. i overally think they are lt, i am just saying i liked their response.

[Starboy]

@soweli

I never claimed my reasons were good to be quite honest with you my attatchment to the read is only in salvaging its conclusion posthumously because you’ve been acting overly defensive about it (I mean your posts outside of that subject have been ~fine and i would unvote if you asked nicely; only reason i’m still voting you is because i don’t have a better option (Marluna doesn’t count for “reasons” (read ‘reasons’ as “weird strategy purposes”)

This confirms my previous feel that the defensiveness of the read came from being asked directly to justify it. If soweli isn’t defending their read on its own merit, I actually think the way they’re trying to find something from what we had at the time somewhat towny.

Also, not game related, but this is their second post now to use parenthesis and not close them properly! This is irrationally annoying me even though it does not matter even in the slightest.

@soweli

(I mean your posts outside of that subject have been ~fine and i would unvote if you asked nicely; only reason i’m still voting you is because i don’t have a better option (Marluna doesn’t count for “reasons” (read ‘reasons’ as “weird strategy purposes”)

))

@soweli

“i scrolled up and picked the first person who [not sure what my specific criteria was but likely ‘looks bad’”

]

closed them for you

[Jarek]

@Starboy

but this reads like a bit of a stretch to me. The town, as Jarek had said, had more or less moved on. I find it unlikely that Kiiruma would pop into thread, and attempt to divert away from an already dying disscussion. If anything I think, if Kiiruma is attempting to direct us, would be directing us back onto the disscussion.

A stretch aww come on

[Canping]

Kiiruma can join the thread and do more, ill probably place a vote tomorrow unless something unusual happens.

UNVOTE

[Frostwolf103]

Huh?

[Starboy]

@Canping

i see what you mean, but its not only their response and what i did to just to read them as town. i overally think they are lt, i am just saying i liked their response.

I’m not sure we’re on the same page. I had said that Marluna seemed like an entitled town, and you said you wanted to hear them say it, but I don’t think them saying that read would have helped

[Jarek]

Meh to be fair maybe you’re right but damn do I want to be convinced someone is evil for absolutely no other reason other than the vindication that I’m right

[Starboy]

@Canping

i wanted them to lowkey point it out, those 3 posts were intentionally mentioned

unless this post was saying that you wanted Marluna to point something other than the read I had just made out.

[Frostwolf103]

Ah nevermind, for some reason I thought you were responding to my post, not Marluna.

[soweli]

90% sure he wanted Marluna to point out that those 3 posts were made after the vote

[Host_Account_1]

D1 Votecount

Canping (3): soweli, Chomps, Leafia
Kiiruma (2): Jarek, Starboy
Chomps (1): ElizaThePsycho
Marluna (1): pandora
Heiter (1): Rhea

Not Voting (8): Marluna, Canping, Frostwolf103, Kiiruma, childe, Creature, Heiter, SMILEY