in fact, i will add tutuu to some of them now
1 Like
i hope thats okay?
1 Like
oh yeah sorry i avoided your whisper it was because i was scared of actually convincing you lol
2 Likes
most of the town gave up at that point, so it was actually the smart decision to show less WIM regardless of whoever subbed in and you were always seeing f3 in every world we built
1 Like
Amelia talking about converting YBW anyway was funny though.
2 Likes
thats why i wanted to talk to you, about you seeing f3 in almost* every solve
1 Like
i wouldve converted ybw regardless of her role for the juicy empath/chef bluffs
her being ft was just icing on the cake
she was just mechanically and socially the perfect choice for like 5 different reasons
amelia was actually seeing f3 in every solve we had
but in one theory we discussed keeping ash alive vs amelia and solve silviu/snowe/neb on f6 into f5
so we could lose the game at f5 depending on whoever lived between silviu/neb against snowe
1 Like
litten>ybw>exile eliza>chop snowe instead of silviu/neb> silviu/neb/amelia or amelia/ash/one in silviu/neb was the plan we built but couldn’t push
1 Like
there was no way out
i don’t think anyone could turn this game around + solve damn
1 Like
oops all outsiders f3
1 Like
thats what having a stacked wolfteam does to you
1 Like
every game some of you is just styling on rest of us and i am fed up with it
only time i won was when I was a traveler so that doesn’t even count
this was my 3rd botc i think
1 Like
my first game may and litten just shredded us to bits until there was nothing left
second game magnus destroyed us on d1, i don’t think we will ever see anything like that
third game i was a traveler so it doesn’t count
this is my fourth(or lets say real third) where i sub in to an already lost game but i can see how you guys swept this game hard and its wild
when will i win a botc truly from start to finish 
3 Likes
I blame crich and hazard for not allowing a fiddler between me and silviu on Fall of Rome for lulz
4 Likes
Considering that a Scarlet Woman was in play, I would’ve given it to someone that I could expect to spread false information in the thread, without necessarily being a player that would have to survive until endgame. I wouldn’t have converted YBW, because that Red Herring on the Spy promises potential mayhem even if the Poisoner dies, who knows?
Actually, I would convert May because they play really well as evil with friends to help them, it eliminates a Washerwoman-Raven threat, they neighbour Litten and the pair of them have an excuse to whisper all the time, Litten could receive a bluff before talking to the Investigator, and from a social standpoint it makes it safer to claim a false Chef number (whereas a fake Chef 0 or 1 with YBW, or an Empath 0, just looks blatantly suspicious in late game). I also think it would be funny to give them a scary role after rolling a not-scary role.
I recognise the confirmed!recluse Icet conversion idea and that’s fun, but that was where my head was. I’m not denying that converting YBW was not an exemplary choice with the way it had gone down, though.
2 Likes