why do you expect prisma to be able to do this when this is their first game and they have never seen arete play before
your demands for them as a new player are unreasonable and your suspicion of them boils down to a nonsense preflip āthey ignored my wallpost on areteā which also applies to several other people
Thought so. I have a Level 0 read where if you invite your friends and push them this hard day 1 your usually wolf and your trying to kill your friends early to avoid having to lie to them for an entire game.
Iāve seen itā¦a lot more than youād think lol
i donāt think i would take that approach tbh
i would be more inclined to keep them alive and pocket them (also because killing them immediately is imo more rude than just playing the game and lying to them)
this summarises the main reason i have to suspect him, but also the way he handled arete
his vote on arete also made no sense with the justification that he ādoesnāt care about early game wagonsā when he said that he voted arete so seth wasnāt the leading wagon, and later added that he does actually care about early game wagons for the sake of analysis, so voting someone he didnāt scumread to tie the leading wagon of someone he townreads made no sense, when there were people he suspected more which he could have voted to do the same thing
and thereās also the way he (by his own admission) ascribed motivations to my posts to make a blatantly bad faith push on me, and later gave up after it had been proven he was pulling stuff from thin air
the posts are pretty recent but the context is that magnus somehow described my post towards may during RVS in which i disagreed with her eliza scumread as me trying to get them to double down on it (???) and then create eliza/may v/v wagons because i started scumreading eliza later
Pushing ungenuine narratives as town is awesome and owns. I have a neutral read on Magnus, but throwing around ideas and seeing what sticks and how people react is NAI.
Trying to mimic what I did with Arete?
Good Luck later when Arete is pushing you and you realize heās wolf but itās your own damn fucking fault for MLing me cause and now your also gonna be MLāed for it.
(Of course this is assuming my town read on you is correct and Iām pretty sure it is.)
Thatās all you have to say?
You want to bring me more pain?
As I said.
Magnus is Town.
Magnus is never a wolf with Prisma.
Prisma and Arete are very likely both wolves.
Here comes the Magnus ML I was talking about, then we will get the May night kill, Iāll brag about the fact I told you all they were both obvious town and tell you itās your last chance to vote Arete, you donāt listen again and ML again so I just being a fucking asshole to spite you all and later on when someone is in a 1v1 with Arete Iāll vote them and say āwhere the hell were you when I was pushing Arete before, I had good case, fuck yours.ā
Getting ready for that May night kill after Magnus execution?
i think zorvoās pushes on arete and prisma (while the reasoning is incredibly dubious) show a level of passable conviction and other posts heās made bloating about his accuracy read as though he genuinely believes what heās saying
magnus on the other hand has been, as neon put it, validating sethās incoherent nonsense in a way that lands seth the blame for his antics. yes, may and magnus, it is incoherent. as someone without TMI, who does not know the alignment of players in this game, i cannot read sethās posts and follow his reasoning nor be convinced on his reads - when they are clearly based entirely on mistruths, strawmans or misrepresentations. i donāt care what your experience with seth is. frankly, if youāve found his reads to be accurate then you have not played enough games with him. the entire game is telling you it is incoherent because it is! and you pretending itās not, and trying to enable him, and acting like his reasons are convincing, while letting him burn the house down, is why i think you two are likely to be mafia
i can buy that people are willing to entertain stuff they donāt necessarily believe in, both to test the validity of ideas and gauge reactions i cannot, however, buy that a villager plays the entire day phase in this way, without making their own stances clear and trying to co-operate with others on where they believe their reads to be wrong
but this is not what magnus has been doing, is it? where has he gauged areteās (or anyone elseās) response to him jumping on their wagon with seth? where has he gauged anyoneās response to him entertaining sethās prisma/arete w/w read? what heās been doing has not been to gauge reactions, or investigate responses. itās been to piggyback on the reads of others while taking very little responsibility for his own actions
could you even tell me who magnus would actually want executed at eod?
this is one of the oldest scumtells in the book. because heās playing it by ear, heās seeing what will be viable and what isnāt, rather than having genuine convictions in who ought to be executed