Bland & Flavorless Mountainous 15er - Mafia Winnered

Forum Games Completed
,
#1421

@Prisma101, to be fair, May did explicitly say this about reading Otter from the quote you posted.

But are you more so pointing out the fact that you liked the way May formed their reads on Otter for why she could be mafia or be town? And you felt like that reasoning came from a townie?

#1422

Man, I feel like an unretired Katze, a charming SPF, and an ego Ilario all in one.

I’m feeling it now hehe.

#1423

okay

I’m going to try to rephrase my question but idk if it’ll be any clearer sorry

why do you think May would be more likely to say they have played with otter before as town than as Mafia? if there is a reason you think May would not want to say this as Mafia you can just say that

why do you think May would be more likely to give these reasons, or to say it could be wolfy or townie, as town?

#1424

@Arete-sama, I know you wanted to chat more and see some of my reads.

I was wondering if I could get ur thoughts on some of my reads/gameview rn, though I am still building it and will have a better idea of it later tn hopefully with a specific reads list.

#1425

am on mobile at work currently so this is going to be pretty short but

I’m confused by your logic for why May should think Otter is town? Like I don’t think May is saying “if Otter is in a new environment, they are town,” I parse May as saying “Otter is being sus, but another possible explanation is that they are town being thrown off by the new environment”

I don’t really think your logic for the Otter wagon being pure in v/v worlds holds (like it could still be true but not for the reason you think it is) – I agree that wolves would probably rather not push it over the Magnus wagon since that could ‘look bad,’ but I think in a v/v world they would be totally happy to hop on it as long as it didn’t go above the top wagon, and they wouldn’t have a reason to get off it (idk if I’m explaining it well)

I agree with your read that Arctic and I aren’t w/w

I think you’re probably wrong about me n1ing you of I were a wolf but I’m not confident in that :joy_cat:

idk how you’re feeling about Prisma currently but I thought some of their responses to my questions felt uninformed

#1426

–uh for clarity Prisma when you read this the thing I mean is “you don’t have extra information, unlike the Mafia,” not “you’re ignorant” or anything

#1427

Lmao. No you aren’t, Arete is.

What kinda read is Bolded?

#1428

Arete just popping into the Convo of Prisma/Aro is so fucking weird NGL.

#1429

I open thread at work

I see not explained read that I expect could be strongly AI

I ask for read to be explained

you’re welcome to think it’s weird but it won’t make you any more correct :joy_cat:

#1430

Bolded?

#1431

he’s asking about the part he put in bold, where you said that I’m “maybe mafia maybe town”

#1432

yeah but why did he say what kind of read is bolded? is he trying to say that i put it in bold and thats suspicious?

#1433

I will discuss more later for the points you brought up and specifically about May and Otter. I was also debunking one of the reasons May had Otter as scum, since I believed that Otter made some “subjective” call outs and the way May has been playing, lines up with how she stated she’d play since this was her first game here on FOL. So that’s why I was wondering from May’s POV if it would make more sense that Otter is town rather than mafia based on how her reads/intentions have matched up with her play so far coming into this game.

I do believe Prisma is likely town and feel the same way you do about “being uninformed” and especially feels pretty natural in their responses and how they approach others for their first forum game and I like some of their responses to my questions.

I was also wondering if you could discuss about my thoughts/read on Eliza and how do you feel about her currently?

I also realized that on the Magnus wagon: you, Zorvo, Otter, Prisma, and Arctic. If you do believe it’s not pure on the wagon, who do you believe is the likeliest to be mafia on that wagon?

#1434

what answers were they again?

zorvo says me or arctic :P

#1435

no, he is pointing out a specific part in what u said in a “bolded format” and wanted to understand ur read from the part that was bolded.

Zorvo bolded that part of the post, you didn’t lol.

And while we are on that topic, if you had to lean Arete one way or another, what’s your feeling about Arete? Likelier to be town or mafia?

#1436

i dunno ig neutral but i dont think thats an option

#1437

They were ur answers about why u were tr May and who you were tr/sr. Though I disagree with your Zorvo read, I like how you elaborated on it and I can see ur thought process behind it.

And Zorvo is pushing Arete the hardest rn lol. He has you guys in POE as well rn, but I believe he wants to kill Arete the most.

#1438

ok that’s fine. So if you don’t mind me asking, were you town reading Arete yesterday for being “helpful towards you”?

#1439

i got arete and either may or neon mixed up

and people were criticizing me for that specific reason i tr arete

#1440

so who was that specific read meant for? Was that a read you meant to make on Arete?

And if that read you meant to make was on Arete, what is the reason you have him as neutral now? Is it because of the people that were criticizing you of that read?