Optimally is is best to exile you
Fun wise
VOTE: Crichard
Wrong. It’s never optimal to exile me and you know it. If you exile me, then you’ll never know if you can trust me or not. If my ability activates, you’ll know you can trust me.
Incorrect. It is mechanically optimal to exile you because we do not care about your alignment.
You’re a skilled enough player to know this if you’re good.
The reason we are executing Richard is to feed him to the cannibal and to eliminate me from being fearful of being a marioniette, we do not really care about his alignment as much as we care about what noble results we get from the cannibal, which will help us determine what world we live in.
Nope. I’m right because knowing who you can trust is powerful info and you know it. If you didn’t care about my alignment, then you wouldn’t be exiling me Litten.
Exiling you is to get rid of your ability.
By not exiling me, you get that same info though. Most travellers are good Litten and my ability is very unlikely to activate this early anyway.
Cannibal only eats the executed person who was killed.
That’s liter adds lly antitown Litten and you know it. You gain nothing exiling me over letting my ability activate.
Yes. We gained exactly what I said we gained.
I know but if you’re so worried about CRich, you can just execute him tomorrow if I get executed in his place and you gain knowledge of my alignment too.
We want his ability.
You don’t gain anything you can’t gain from not exiling me Litten.
The problem is time
Like I get what you are saying
But the cannibal isn’t going to live forever if he’s legit
CRich already has that a bbn ility so that argument doesn’t hold water. Exiling me isn’t the play Litten.
Their bounty is Marluna/Amelia/hazard which for obviously reasons is not really useful
Like the reason we want it is to determine what demon we are dealing with
Not exactly true.
If Cannibal gains Scapegoat’s ability, there is a chance they will be executed next time, when we try to feed someone to the cannibal.
And if they don’t they will definetly killed that night.
1 Like
Can a Cannibal even gain a scapegoat’s ability?