BOTC/BOTF Discussion Thread 2

Game Discussion
#4382

i feel like on average it’s just worse than a demon that says [+the Damsel] which would be a strange demon but one that’s ~relatively weak

(though that part is just because the Damsel can’t be guessed after they die)

2 Likes
#4383

I like the concept though

#4384

could maybe do something where the st chooses which of their kills go through?

1 Like
#4385

in general it’s probably worth nerfing the good demon’s killpower but i think the idea is that Minions can kind of know who they are, but need to figure out which is which a la Magician

#4386

there is also the issue of minions basically being able to just 50/50 guess and potentially win like d1

1 Like
#4387

ye
im thinking that it could do with demons not knowing the minions at all but that’s just a gut instinct

for killpower perhaps just say “each night*, a player might die” (st controlled kills)
and you would also have to clarify if Good needs to kill the Good Demon (rn they do, which seems unintentional)

#4388

i think if you give it st controlled kills it could probably use a buff elsewhere but i’m not sure what that would be

#4389

no they do need to kill the good demon thsts intentional, but also at that point the good demon can just kill themselves at night

#4390

ah right ok fair

#4391

I dont like st controlled kills and dont think its very fun, letting one of teo go through works better imo

1 Like
#4392

ye maybe just give it a might on the ability in general

#4393

i do think that guessing the good demon is exceedingly easy rn and that the minions should just learn a poe?
the poe would be based on playercount but thats’ stupid to word so it would probably just be generally ST decided if u care about length

#4394

i dont like the idea of a poe like at all, i want minions to learn both but there also be a consequence for the good one getting “caught”

1 Like
#4395

ye fair

#4396

it just feels… relatively easy to catch which one is which
i’m really not certain tho

#4397

i feel like it shouldnt be that eays but the only worry I have is its literally a 50/50 chance

1 Like
#4398

ye

#4399

it definitely takes a modification in play from the evil demon imo

#4400

I’m pretty sure there’s something. Sorta like this in the unreleased category but i couldnt tell you much more about it

1 Like
#4401

Um as for the like. Actual character
Before I say anything im pretty sure all demons wake together for demon info which could be problematic !!!

But ignoring that uh, 50/50 chance to win is worse than Mole, and the good demon has to also discreetly get the evil demon (and potentially itself) killed which is a gargantuan task

2 Likes