BOTC/BOTF Discussion Thread 2

You aren’t wasting my time. I’d want everyone to understand the process behind every decision made, because nothing was “arbitrary”.

1 Like

I don’t see the problem with giving me that information during the Night. I mean, when the hell do you think Dreams happen?

1 Like

You could’ve changed your action since it wasn’t locked, is the only problem.
Plus it would suggest that the demon had already acted by the time you received your information which gives you a false narrative of when the demon might be awake.

Yeah but people usually dream at night

2 Likes

(I am joking)

4 Likes

For the record, I initially thought she was so obviously the Damsel that I didn’t want to put her in danger by whispering, and then I forgot I thought this and was like “well Zone’s so obviously the convert” because I do no insignificant amount of clownery.

1 Like

Not even forgot, honestly. Just dismissed. I need to value my past self’s opinions more.

1 Like

I guess I did consider when she first made the guess that she was good Damsel doing a play, but I had forgotten that a Damsel would be one of the most likely townsfolk to get converted.

^ Guy who is later going to assume Bellatrix’s guess there was a serious, good-faith attempt from a Minion to win (barring incompetence)

They put my thoughts in the randomiser every day this is well documented. I think I was much better at mafia back when I actually took notes. I should do that. I got some good notebooks recently

1 Like

this is an interaction that can happen in snv
the one time ive seen this happen the STs just went and killed the philo with arbitrary deaths because they didn’t want to out that their neighbour was exactly the no dashii who turned into the fang gu

i didnt even talk to you d1 lol

You made like four Damsel jokes and were incredibly evasive about your role

1 Like

1 Like

did you talk to kii/cas/crich on d1
i dont remember
but fair enough yeah

i made those damsel jokes consciously because i thought that the evil team would be looking for people who actively avoided making damsel jokes lol

also if you look at any one of those whispers i wasnt remotely evasive about my role
its only when you realise that i was very forthcoming about being a different role to each persn :wowee:

1 Like

I whispered Caspore and that’s it, I think. I didn’t do a lot of whispers. Other reason I didn’t want to whisper you - I knew if I claimed Dreamer later and you were still alive and unguessed, it would be really easy to figure out why I was being evasive about my D1 investigation, and so I didn’t want to leave a whisper trail back to you. In fact, I very specifically wanted to leave a fake whisper trail back to Caspore, and I even considered asking her if I could pretend I saw her as Damsel.

Obviously, I could’ve just whispered more people to hide who exactly it was I investigated, but I was sleepy and didn’t want to do it.

1 Like

Hey, that’s genetic bias

1 Like

This one I gotta protest. How on earth is it genetic bias

1 Like

It insinuates that the knowledge that has its source from you should also have been known by others when it isn’t the case.

Therefore knowledge genetic to you is genetic bias

2 Likes

Twitter arguments be like

Ugh, genetic bias again!