BoTF XIII.1 Grave Digging and Filling Day Six (Final Day) Evil Win

Forum Games Completed
,
#1561

How so?

#1562

bc your barista and it went on an evil player

#1563

its supposed to be postively beneficial for the team your on

1 Like
#1564

It could also be equally beneficial if it was on a town player, since it makes me look town as well. This is Bleh.

#1565

Also, the only reason my ability would target evil!dum when Iā€™m evil is if Dum is either exactly the demon, or the poisoner

#1566

We can rule out Demon, because only 1 player died (presumably from the Demon) on the 1st night, which means that if Iā€™m evil, Dum is (most likely) poisoner.

#1567

Another way to say this is that either of my abilities would have had no effect on a Demon (except for Pukka, which only 1 player died from the demon), and on a Minion (except for poisoner, which isnā€™t ruled out here.)
If Dum is evil, my ability would have been wasted, regardless of what they were (with the exception of Poisoner in this case.)

#1568

Also, even if you do accept that my ability would have been wasted on evil Dum, youā€™d also have to accept that Kiiruma is evil, since my ability targeted them as well.

#1569

Speaking of Barrister, Who was Baristaā€™d last night?

#1570

Or it was confirming to evil team who evil traveller is

#1571

Or it could be falsely confirming that I am evil.

It could be anything, and weā€™re not gonna get anywhere speculating on smoke

#1572

I mean
What else are we gonna do

#1573

Not try to mech solve an un-mech-solvable game?

#1574

ah yes
let me use my killer social reads

#1575

Thereā€™s a very good reason why Mafia is called a Social Deduction game.

#1576

Thereā€™s a very good reason why rolesā€¦ have abilitiesā€¦ that let us use mechanics with the social elements :D

2 Likes
#1577

Yes, but after a certain point you speculate on smoke rather than facts.

#1578

Consider it confirmed. I, at the very least, claimed Undertaker in whispers.
(Why no ping?)

#1579

pinging is for nerds

#1580

why