im intrigued at what windy’s claiming but I still think that magnus’s claim is extremely spyish and eggyolks claim is extremely demonish
egg - townsfolk
omega - outsider
whysper - demon
windy - minion (poisoned)
i think its far more likely that you just… pinged the demon first? I don’t see what’s wrong with that?
occam’s razor says it’s not a baron vigor game and magnus is the spy or him/eggyolk is no dashii poisoning me
if eggyolk is the no dashii then me and magnus are both poisoned
whysper isn’t the poisoner, isn’t the baron, isn’t the spy, has to be the sw
atlas’s pings are egg (demon), omega (outsider), whysper (minion), windy (townsfolk)
nancy/whysper is the red herring
3rd minion would… have to be amelia the spy?
For us to both be good in this world it has to be baron sw
Red herring can only be town
Theres only two
i can ping off magnus the spy, like ive said about 20 times so far?
Oh yeah right
I mean
Does it register as specific characters or just outsider
/town
it can register as specific characters
undertaker can see an executed spy as the philosopher
washerwoman can see a spy as the empath
librarian can see a spy as the drunk
1 Like
This, of course, opens up many wacky interactions because of course it does
1 Like
If its baron sw wouldnt we have another outsider
1 Like
Baron sw balloon
3 outsiders
Is it worth nomming Magnus or is he definitely not the demon?
There’s no reason not to nom someone unless there’s someone better to nom in mind.
I’m fine with being nommed fwiw since I only claimed to Kii tbf, I don’t expect you guys to think I’m town but if Nancy was the demon the game would’ve been in a much different state by now since she clearly did nothing
1 Like
The other slot I would’ve nommed is already nommed
I have no idea when it’s a good idea to openly claim so I haven’t done that
1 Like
I’m really bad at figuring out appropriate timing for claims (and fake claims for that matter) in botf