technically
3 Likes
Pfft. Is anything truly random outside rand?
the sweetheart ability would’ve been considered townsfolk because that was my alignment
and it would probably drunk a minion (or a dead player)
but it wouldn’t drunk the demon
1 Like
coward
2 Likes
sounds like excuses to pick an outsider as philo
i couldn’t be jumped because my alignment didn’t change
i think
yeah you couldn’t be jumped, you just have the ability
1 Like
@Bellatrix if the Philosopher were to pick the sweetheart ability, would it be ruled akin to a townsfolk or an outsider in the most typical engagement
im bored
and kinda tired so
im gonna do something else for a bit and come back
1 Like
things to be figured out
math 2
info 2
Magnus
jarek/ybw
jarek/squirrel
eliza/ybw seam info
This leaning certainly varies from Storyteller to Storyteller, as there is nothing in the rules preventing you from running it either way.
Personally, when the Philosopher chooses to gain an Heretic ability, I will usually use any leeway that I have in its ability to favor the Good team. This is because the Philosopher’s gaining of an ability is the powerful section of its role, and Philosopher is an Imperialist. I will therefore use the Philosopher’s ability to help the Good team like any other Imperialists.
This is separate from how I would run the Cannibal (Imperialist, not on the script), since I deem the Cannibal’s most powerful part of their role to be the accrual of information from executed players, not the uses of their abilities. Executing Heretics is an intended drawback for the Cannibal.
Many Heretics have no such leeway in Storyteller decisions.
3 Likes
Sweetheart would’ve been a good pick, then.
COOL
We could’ve had an outcasts squad.
Okay anyway who wants to kill Magnus so he doesn’t get to have fun
I veto this idea.
I will know.
Is this an evil claim?
How would you know?