BotF XVI - Calm Before the Storm - Shattered Futures [Starseekers Win]

I wanted to spark discussion, of course. The thread was entirely dead, so I started putting words together.

jeffery cheezits legume spike open kill soiib disassociation jarek scum

i mean yeah but like

in a marluna eliza jarek world what can they even do in this situation

2/3 are outed the third is under heavy suspicion, is being thunderdomed, and is also just generally not active

1 Like

Everyone in the Town was quiet.

Not just the leading suspects.

yeah i’ve been quiet because i’ve been working on finals

At least you have a reason. I’m not sure how many others do.

No I’m the athest

2 Likes

The identifying factor between (Vortox) Mist and (No Dashii) Marluna should be Squirrel’s Savant information.

Except the only player who could’ve selected an evil player is Marluna.

Because Squirrel visited the Storytellers before Mist juggled.

Can I counterclaim Atheist and make us doppelgängers again?

1 Like

that one works in both worlds iirc?

since if marluna is good she targeted eliza and if not then no one acted

2 Likes

oh yeah and fwiw i do think marluna eliza are super socially w/w

so there’s that too

1 Like

what

what

have we even ever interacted???

How does it make sense for Marluna to be the Demon? As Atlas said, she didn’t whisper anyone on the first day. I know the Cerenovus and Pit Hag weren’t communicating, since otherwise Jarek’s Mutant ploy and Squirrel’s Mutant swap contradiction wouldn’t have come up, but I’d at least expect the Demon to whisper someone, anybody. But the Seamstress check was so weird.

Has anyone got a Marluna Mafia game, or an evil BOTF game, I could look at?

None that I know of. It’s true that the Demon is expected to whisper their minions, yet we know that evils haven’t been coordinating their actions the best this game.

1 Like

mist can’t be vortox because of ybw’s math numbers
i think

1 Like

either me or squirrel malfunctioned n1
math would have to get a 2+

well
thats
exactly if i malfunctioned because squirrel can’t act n1

then there was a 2 n2
that couldve been squirrel malfunctioning and vortox
hm