BotF XVI - Calm Before the Storm - Shattered Futures [Starseekers Win]

Forum Games Completed
,
#1561

How possible is a CRichard/Atlas/Marluna team in a Vortox game, with the latter trying to save their Demon by trying a play? For the sake of theorycrafting.

#1562

then the games gonna end

#1563

I’m not hinging everything on the game ending today, I’m just throwing it out there.

#1564

theres no point
crich is dying
im making sure of it

#1565

If CRichard’s the Demon and there’s a Minion voting them, it’s technically possible for evil to tie the vote today. Which would out him immediately… and then the Pit Hag is forced to make a new Demon, probably.
And that would rely on nobody else voting him afterward.

So… it’s alright, huh.

#1566

CRichard can be mechanically good, I think. But it’s still kinda wacky.

#1567

well
i hooe you judge a lot more in your read accuracy than mine
because when crich flips and if the game doesn’t end im assuming your the minion wasting our time

#1568

Why can’t CRich be a Minion, exactly? I’m in pretty good standing rn.

#1569
  1. i’ll take the one vote over none
  2. may i remind you you’re accusing him of being demon and me of being his minion
#1570

Question: what made @Marluna check Eliza and YBW last night?

#1571

Unless I made up the Math 1 and got a lucky shot in the dark, I don’t think I can be evil. Socially.

#1572

you could very easily make up math one

#1573

So I make up Math 1, and claim it to YBW outright.

This would mean I’m hardclaiming a role before I receive a bluff.

I then whisper Jarek, and they claim Philo Clockmaker.
Prisma claims Philo Clockmaker publicly.

Nobody else has an obvious source of poisoning, although a Vortox is always possible (and kinda likely, ig?). Where’s the leak of information, here?

#1574

this feels like a strawman lmao

#1575

Probably is.

#1576

ok

1 Like
#1577

Oh, I didn’t realise this part.
I thought tied votes would result in no execution, same as BOTC.

#1578

ybw is evil
jarek is evil
you’re evil
prisma’s evil
any one of these four conclusions

#1579

vortox

1 Like
#1580

This works if I’m neither No Dashii or Vortox poisoning Prisma, to your credit. That would also violate Marluna’s claimed seamstress results (that Eliza and YBW are the same faction).

So Jarek claims Philo Poisoning, and we just get lucky that Prisma claims Philosopher before I’d know that. I think I would have to be No Dashii or Vortox in this case, if Prisma and YBW are both good in this simulation.

Doesn’t really work for reasons.

Prisma claims true clockmaker results, good!Jarek claims false results, makes me exactly Vortox, which (again) means YBW or Eliza would have to be a minion.
Which is mechanically sound, maybe, but doesn’t work socially because Prisma would’ve needed to claim that without my prompt.