BotF XVII: U-Pick Your Poison - D6 - Lil Monsta (And the Evil Team) Wins!

Forum Games Completed
,
#6101

why

#6102

Amelia as the Puzzlemaster after guessing received Atlas’ name.
If Amelia is the host then nobody is actually puzzledrunk and Amelia would also be poisoned.

Sure it’s technically possible to tell Amelia the legit demon there but it feels a tad wild

1 Like
#6103

No, I mean, we would have no way to know if Amelia is the leeched because Lleech abilities are very dumb :sob:

#6104

You can’t meta the storytellers.

1 Like
#6105

if puzzlemaster is poisoned then is no one puzzledrunk?

#6106

I mean - You can try, but it’s not going to go well for you :stuck_out_tongue:

#6107

@jared from subway

#6108

As far as I know puzzledrunkedness is a set-up thing much like marionette and drunk and therefore someone would still be puzzledrunk.

1 Like
#6109

If you are poisoned your ability malfunctions.

If this is to an investigative character (E.G. Balloonist, Dreamer etc.) then this means the ST may lie to you.

In the case of a more mechanical and utility ability (such as the Puzzlemaster making someone drunk) this does not happen.

2 Likes
#6110

Well then BoTF is actually a whacky game that a select few are playing!

#6111

Or well I guess the STs run it this way and that’s what matters in this case

1 Like
#6112

:sob:

#6113

Set-up abilities aren’t affected by poison that would be really silly

“haha lol I poisoned the baron so there’s not actually 2 outsiders”

#6114

The Puzzledrunk isn’t a part of setup.

3 Likes
#6115

disgust

#6116

[+2 outsiders] is the setup ability

Puzzlemaster on the other hand does not have these square brackets and instructions inside. Which therefore means it’s not setup as much as it is for Atheist or Baron or Lil Monsta. The bracketed things are required setup changes.

#6117

It’s magnus’ game I’m just here to post cat slimes over and over again so you listen to magnus not me

1 Like
#6118

I am the evil one after all :sa:

1 Like
#6119

So therefore since we’d be running it via Magnus’ rulings, then there would be no puzzledrunk if Amelia is hosted.

#6120

is there any reason this doesn’t work