You’re rewarding the good team for taking the risk to execute.
1 Like
You’re underestimating how dumb town can be sometimes and itwould depend on how convincing and trusted the demon was. As well as how trusted the mayor was.
1 Like
By the way, don’t execute on four in a Legion game, either. You’ll put the ST into an awkward spot if you kill a Legion.
I do not assume people are stupid when playing botc, not unless it was all beginners
1 Like
Wdym
You pretty much force the ST to no-kill or kingmake.
1 Like
Or if the evils didn’t trust the soldier claim. Or the kill was stopped somehow. You are right that a smart town would virtually always win though.
1 Like
what should the st do in that situation
The correct decision is to kill the Mayor because it relates to how the players ran the game. Bouncing the final nightkill into the soldier is just too much ST-dabble for me.
1 Like
town correctly killed a demon
Yeah. I’d agree with you unless the town really worked hard for a win up to that point and evilsdidn’t do much of anything.
1 Like
if town worked really hard; the demon would be dead
If you no-kill, a Legion will die in the night and you’ll have a proper F3.
In a normal game, if you executed and the game continued on four…
1 Like
the fiddler exists solely to prevent the demon from constantly choosing a dead body right?
botc, the game where people execute and stab corpses for fun
this is like leafia’s fifth execution
Theoretically. It could also be used to break other deadlocks, like an immortal Lleech scenario.
Resolve deadlocks as you see fit, though.
1 Like
Immortal leech?
Mez turned monk protecting the sailor poisoned by the leech
You start by choosing an alive player: they are poisoned - you die if (& only if) they die.
It works the same as Grandmother. If the Lleech is droisoned when their host dies, they live. The “die” condition has already passed, so the host can’t die again and so the Lleech cannot die if they become sober and healthy.
1 Like