Marshal’s slot is town and my Revolutionary claim was spectacular.
(This is not a serious assertion of my reads.)
The vigour in the debate from before isn’t AI but it draws parallels to other unnecessary fakeclaims in the game which have all been from town, and the confrontation with Atlas serving the purpose of creating enough doubt to kill Amelia instead falls short when you think about their Damsel guess claim. Granted, it’s similar enough to the Bellatrix Damsel guess in the last U-Pick; I don’t think Amelia would be the likeliest Damsel. Showing the Demon to the Outsider Executioner is bizarre but it theoretically works with the safety net.
Tutuu’s too easily convinced, no matter the circumstance.