Cookie Thread Act 1: A Cookie in Time

General
#14967

hostbias has already proven to work in a mafia context
See clown fiesta games where hostfiat was a major balancing factor

2 Likes
#14968

i don’t think clown fiesta should be used as a baseline for normal mafia game you basically just pointed to someone in a padded cell

1 Like
#14969

roles like vizier just have a high toxicity quotient
you need to design entirely around them but otherwise they are fine even if most people don’t want to play with them

1 Like
#14970

BotC is literally mafia for insane people

2 Likes
#14971

There is an audience

1 Like
#14972

vizier in a mafia setting just removes that pesky system of “voting where you feel like it”

1 Like
#14973

why do you think i’m so good at it

#14974

if anyone votes a town as a joke insta hammer them and then nightkill them

1 Like
#14975

your honor, VOTE: Atlas

#14976

vizier requires curating the playerlist as well
if someone doesn’t read the op the game is fucked

1 Like
#14977

i simultaneously agree and disagree with your opinion. i will not be taking questions

1 Like
#14978

whats your opinion on carrots

#14979

Carrots are too high in carbohydrates

#14980

some random fucking kp 1x
town 1-shot governer 1x
vanilla town 8x
mafia goon 2x (2-shot success factional vizier)

I have not used any sort of numbers on this

2 Likes
#14981

probably an odd-night vigilante

#14982

they’re extremely low if you arent going for a keto low carb, and are even encouraged for medium diets or liberal low carbs

#14983

Governor is a worthy inclusion

1 Like
#14984

I don’t like it usually but when the alternative is ‘day can last literally 5 minutes’ then I would argue it necessary

1 Like
#14985

i think an important inclusion to vizier people just completely forgot to mention is that they’re not straight immortal but instead lynchproof

1 Like
#14986

it’s a completely valid solution to just blow their brains out on the spot

1 Like