Cookie Thread Act 1: A Cookie in Time

no we’ve been fucking up your day on purpose

1 Like

the only way you could fuck up my day purely through setups is by being the mu champs shotcallers and, by doing so, being an affront to good setup design

1 Like

“All players keep their eyes closed when voting & the vote tally is secret. Votes for you only count if you vote.”

votes are secret and the organ grinder is immune to execution unless they self-vote. they don’t need to die in order for the good team to win, though. so if they’re outed evil at the end, it could work against evil

1 Like

this works incredibly poorly in real life

1 Like

as someone who’s hosted irl mafia

2 Likes

if your argument is that players need to be trusted not to peek, youre doing that anyway

1 Like

nope
it’s more an issue of it slowing down the game substantially to make sure people don’t fuck up

2 Likes

deceive inc 10er was based on an irl mafia setup that i played

i forgot to mention this in the thread :wowee:

wait deceive inc is an irl mafia game

if your worry is about slowing the game down, you should hear about leviathan

1 Like

the only difference being that i played it with 7 or 8 players which uh

i woke up at 1 am for this

1 Like

no that’s just the flavor

the setup is based on irl mafia

as for organ grinder’s merits
I’m not even sure why you would put this in a setup
It’s one of those roles that just has ‘why’ plastered all over it

2 Likes

they promised like 45 minions

1 Like

au’wre is leviathan but well designed

It genuinely has no positives to its inclusion