Cookie Thread Act 1: A Cookie in Time

they surely exist they are just not coming to mind

i guess the most benguined anecdote is that one time i got ita’ed to death over the course of 10 minutes because everyone decided i was a lost wolf but i’m not sure if that’s the most me anecdote, y’know

2 Likes

The most May mafia anecdote might be that time I found caught a wolf by going up to someone & saying “hey wanna roll a die to figure out who to push”, and then the person I DMed flipped wolf, and I was silenced the next day for being too epic win, and then the day after that I did it again and they were both wolves again. All the while my survivor buddy was yelling at me because “it is not even your wincon to kill the mafia” and “you are going to get killed that is literally the only thing we don’t want”

one time Achromatic was (incorrectly) scumreading me in a mafia game and not reevaluating and I started quoting a Pathfinder fanfic written by the Most Annoying Person On The Internet at him about it

(the fact that one of the authors of the fic was the Most Annoying Person On The Internet isn’t relevant I just want to be absolutely sure no one thinks I necessarily agree with other things the author has said)

1 Like

Remember that time you were arguing with Zorvo in B&F and you pulled out the Brier scores

oh my god

I forgot about it but now I remember

i think the most me discord mafia moment might be when i caught a mafia in the blaseball game because they said they didn’t understand the echo ability that every wyatt mason had and they were claiming a wyatt mason

1 Like

Was Summers Preston in that game

no

Wow. 1984

The 1st anon game I played was on old FOL. I was NE that game.

Literally the best Wyatt Mason (the fact that she was ever one is extremely obscure trivia)

i was neutral to maybe town reading them up until they said this it was like something clicked. felt like an ace attorney moment

1 Like

something in my room’s making my allergies flare up and now I have a fever instead of itches everywhere after consuming antihistamines, even though I supposedly have 0 allergies

AMA

I played an anon game once. I randed wolf, froze a little but managed to get into thread D1 and sound reasonable and analytical so just about everyone townread me.

Just about.

At EoD1 my role was revealed to be in the game due to a moderror, the circumstances of the exact role meant everyone was able to figure out I had it, I was outed as not acting at all like a bulletproof townie should, and then at SoD2 a 3P posted a massive wolfcase on me and Litten saw it and, having previously been the Only person scumreading me on D1, immediately hipfired at me & Marl, not knowing who either of us were, just happening to hit two of the FoLers in the game, and was the only villager to kill a wolf nearly all game

welcome to the thread, please share your most characteristically you anecdote

1 Like

Still think he should’ve been the only villager to kill a wolf Ever that would’ve been epic

Marl was town FTR. And it was a suicide bomb Litten died too. We all died

I still remember the Anon game as though it was yesterday, because someone kept spamming the thread with someone being scum which made it unenjoyable for most of the town. It didn’t help this player was neutral evil.
So the hosts were in a real pickle to say the least.

Still on my list of favorite mafia interactions is eevee posting a screenshot of a timestamp to argue that they hadn’t seen a particular post, and therefore wasn’t a perspective slip

People accused eevee of photoshopping

Then they argued that it’d be against the rules for angleshoooting? or something else, along with other people

Then it turned out they actually had indeed photoshopped

All while being town

Therefore not perspective slipping