How else are you meant to know what the Demon’s bluffing?
Oh they were gonna nightkill one of us anyway (Lil’ Monsta) so it ended up beneficial in the long run cause it gave the team who got executed by Cerenovus enough credit to push themselves over the finish line. Because surely no evil team wouod be dumb enough to dot hat shit
1 Like
did they change the rulings on whispers because i know damn well that this is exactly 1:1 how i killed the mutant in botf2
“by the way mutant claimed to me in whispers”
credits
It’s always been this way as far as I know.
I mean yeah you can still say this as evil
1 Like
You can snitch.
I Cerenovused them because they didn’t have a bluff and it was like D3 so they needed one badly
And that way I 1. Handed them a bluff 2. Let them have an out if it failed/ended up a double claim
yeah that’s the point you snitch but they didn’t hold the whisper against them until they snitched
The ST is at liberty to execute the Mutant if they claim being an Outsider anywhere.
I was once targeted by the Cerenovus as the Demon because they didn’t want me to change my bluff too much.
1 Like
I feel like harpy madness would genuinely be negative utility if we went with the no whisper listening thing 
1 Like
I think everyoneshould see Coffee on the Pillarcentre my greatest social deduction achievement
The first statement does not contradict what we said
The second statement says nothing about “you won’t get executed for doing this”
1 Like
the first statement wouldn’t exist if the storyteller could execute them on the spot for the whisper
the witch snitched to the storyteller and only the storyteller
1 Like
The ST isn’t omnipresent irl
1 Like
“Avoid mentioning your true identity within earshot of the Storyteller, but also be wary about revealing to suspected evil players - they can tell the Storyteller what you’ve said, and get you killed that way!”
that’s literally the point