Cookie Thread Act 3: The Cookie Strikes Back

General
#24864

Colours are important. In avatar selection

1 Like
#24865

Why don’t they just slay the princess? Are they stupid?

1 Like
#24866

name your favorite circlemaf mechanic of the following:

  • the mafia having 4 players out of 32 total
  • the cult being allowed to recruit from the mafia, thus dropping their numbers to 3 midgame
  • the cult not knowing their wincon to start off the game
  • the cult’s wincon being borderline impossible
  • the cult’s wincon being changed midgame to a normal cult wincon when this was realized
  • the 3p role that randomized all night action targets
  • deadchat mechanics, including two different layers of dead, with the only reviver being a 3p who just had to revive people and cared not for the details
  • one of the deadchat mechanics showing a player the last five messages in someone else’s role channel, which was a scumchat if scum was chosen
  • alignments flipping in a game with deadchat mechanics
  • the mafia role that made mafia members flip as town until they died
  • the cult role that made the entire cult investigate as town
  • town having a 5x voter, who unsurprisingly got culted
  • the role that automatically died to start the game, flipped town, won if either mafia or cult won, and moved people through the layers of deadness
2 Likes
#24867

how does your site have more oldfol game design moments than actual oldfol

#24868

note that i got killed by the cult n1, resurrected n2, culted by the night action randomizer n4, killed by the mafia n5, pretended my second flip was fake due to the precedent of fake flip mechanics, and powerwolfed the deadchat mechanics the rest of the way

#24869

this was a single game

2 Likes
#24870

Don’t worry; this was three years ago. I have improved as a game designer.
I think.
I hope.

#24871

italy i think you have competition

#24872

:camera_flash: :back:

5 Likes
#24873

man who just two months ago advertised a mafia game in signups and then made people play a boardgame that was vaguely mafia adjacent at times

#24874

@Chloe @katze

1 Like
#24875

It was a fun boardgame.
Too town-sided, but I’ve fixed that for the next version.

#24876

its not the same without the caps for emphasis

1 Like
#24877

only died twice though

#24878

Im very very sorry guys

You are all lovely and i didnt expect such a warm reception

I was trolling. Im not dating Lady Gaga. I didnt except that to blow up. I imagined it as a cheap “haha” one-off thingy

I might have gotten carried away with lying about it. Sorry. I feel guilty. You guys are too lovely. I didnt mean to like. Take advantage of your kindness. I just found it hilarious and i didnt believe that id come across as believable

Sorry again, i love you (im serious now!)

Im sorry :frowning:

8 Likes
#24879

shoutout to templar for being the pinnacle of game design

#24880

LMAO

1 Like
#24881

i think the problem back then is that people wanted to host/play large games but then half the game would be inactive in the least surprising twist ever

1 Like
#24882

lets go mets

#24883

32 player games were very standard and 20 was like. the bare minimum. still to an extent is but i think the games have become self selecting for active players now that it’s past pandemic times

1 Like