Cookie Thread Act 3: The Cookie Strikes Back

Magnus won

i like to design setups,get eliza to host then with me and then forget to host them. this happens at least once a month

1 Like

classics maf has warped my ability to create a balanced game because i know what itā€™s like to be mafia in a townsided game. winning is exhilarating if you can pull it off but in the moment shit sucks

Shoutout to Stellaris where we lost like every single coin flip until I survived Bradā€™s 50% gun

1 Like

Which he only had because he won a coin flip

stellaris was townsided and all. but classics makes stellaris look like the biggest cakewalk imaginable for scum

2 Likes

i cannot impress enough how much town had to fumble to lose that game. and they pulled it off and then some

2 Likes

22761_2

1 Like

IDT Stellaris was that townsided in setup we just got horrendously unlucky at first

1 Like

Despite immediately killing the cop and then the tracker

classics started with night 0 for some reason. we got to kill three townies, which almost makes up for the FOUR FUCKING REDCHECKS town got on different mafia members that night

2 Likes

whats this supposed to mean

im not a greater evil im a lesser evil

im sure engineering boy

you know what it means

one of these redchecks was on a commuter and the gm just threw some different role under the bus without even checking. we didnā€™t find out that it was just a normal cop who accidentally got a result for like. months after the game ended

3 Likes

Iā€™m such a perfectionist I could never host a setup I designed itā€™s so embarrassing

1 Like

the fake masonry cult game was one of the best of its time because it was at least vaguely balanced. it wasnā€™t the hostā€™s fault that i played bad and scum got rolled. standards were so so low

may host a game or i will find an excuse to ban you

1 Like

1 Like