Cookie Thread Act 4: katze thread

i miss stalker man

neutral killers are the hardest roles to fit in any game period
they are meant as a balancing tool but they aren’t particularly good at that
and they add super high salt score to the scum since they can just be randomly killed without much counterplay

1 Like

lil spying creep~

1 Like

theyre difficult at best but i think they often take away more than they give even when theyre mechanically balanced

1 Like

losing to the one dude who is also uninformed but wants to kill you isnt an upset its just. boring

this was u when u picked this name

2 Likes

no that was chloe

4 Likes

don’t forget

  • worst neutral role you’ve ever seen, designed custom for the setup by the host
4 Likes

these roles and theorymon thursday mons are exactly the same idk how to explain it you just gotta know

2 Likes

THEORYMON THURSDAY:

Buff idea for Survivor

  • Survivor now has a compulsive roleblock so that it can fakeclaim escort
  • It will still die if it roleblocks the serial killer
  • To win, the Survivor must additionally use their roleblock on players of three different alignments (godfathers count as town)
4 Likes

if it were really like theorymon thursday there would be like 3 or 4 changes to existing roles and 3 or 4 archetypes that are brought up independently every week

1 Like

“what is there was an ability that set trick room” is r/stunfisk’s “what if witch’s vest only protected from scum attacks”

1 Like

i have fantastic news

1 Like

This isn’t even optimized for being shit since you benefit a lot from engaging with the game and reading

1 Like

“trust me THIS time werewolf is balanced”

1 Like

“what if archeops didn’t have defeatist” is r/stunfisk’s “what if framer [blah blah blah]” but the difference is that sometimes bmg implements the framer changes and they’re inevitably way too overtuned

1 Like

The optimal shit neutral genuinely has fucking nothing to do with the game at large

1 Like


hey guys im gonna host a semi open with my new neutral killing, is it balanced

3 Likes

Make it solve like 5 puzzles or something

1 Like

enchanter moment