Poor Approximations of Catgirls - Thread 1

[nightingale]

sorry
nya

im feeling kind of
depressed
right now

you can get me in the morning nya

[Nyarchmage]

TARGET	VOTES	VOTED BY
Marluxion	2/11	Millium (#4635); min (#4632)
Marshal	2/10	Arctic (#4642); nutella (#4535)
nightingale	1/11	alana (#4616)
Squirrel2412	3/11	bladescape (#4480)
Hippopablompoyeetus	1/11	Wazza (#4633)
Not Voting	13	BS4215; Hippopablompoyeetus; Illwei; Kyubey; LASERpointer; Marluxion; Marshal; Mistyx; Moonwink; nightingale; Squirrel2412; WindwardAway; Wisdom

[alana]

Some thoughts:

-it pings me that Hippo first says ‘I feel like the Squirrel wagon was set up to avoid the Arete vs Marshal thunderdome yet then shortly after attempts a cfd on Wisdom by creating a FOURTH wagon

-I feel like Bladescape knows better than to just tunnel a LHFish slot like Squirrel

-I think Squirrel’s long readslist legacy-post at EoD is unlikely to come from scum

-Wisdom’s posts about Marshal and Arete are almost TWTBAW

-Marluxion and Arctic’s feelings about the Arete lynch seem genuine

-I still don’t townread her but Millium’s posts definitely look better today

Will do my own iso of Vulgard tomorrow

[Moonwink]

Howdy. <3

I’m going to explain in a moment why I’m spewed town by Vulgard’s flip in spite of them being a lost wolf. Just need to pull up some posts.

[Arctic]

@Vulgard

feel like there are wolves in the marshal/mistyx/min/squirrel/wazza grouping because I do have townreads on them but those townreads are for shaky reasons and I know from experience that I often put wolves in that zone of my readlists

is this actually a soft
i ask this because he then gave this extra group of 3 which i know know contains at least 2 villagers and he could have just merged this into the first one? i see the difference in the groups was “people i townread but could be a wolf” vs “people i wolfread” but i feel his emphasis is on the first grouping rather than the second, and knowing the second contains 0-1 wolves is making me mrrrr about the first group of 5

@Vulgard

@Vulgard

marshal/mistyx/min/squirrel/wazza

I’d actually say wolves are here + some combo of arctic/JC/Alana

yes, I do realize JC is pushing people in this group, just different ones than me

---

@Marshal

Vulgard can be mafia
Not is but can be

@Vulgard

i can always be mafia
my range is infinite

@Vulgard

@Arctic

nternet feels like eevee tbh

From grammar and claiming european

i had the same thought
he feels like
huh
if it’s eevee, he feels exactly like he played in a certain fol game from 2020 which @Marshal might remember; a game where he roleplayed as someone from an East Asian country and then broke character to insult Marshal’s way of playing mafia before subbing in his main account (yes, this actually happened)

his question to Hippo earlier felt like a 1:1 repeat of the question alt!eevee asked Marshal in that game

is this signalling

@Vulgard

oh yeah i think in fam katze was like “vul is wolfy for not acknowledging these people are town” and the people in question were indeed town but katze was a wolf so like

marshal wolf? lmao

@Vulgard

i guess i lost track of what you were accusing me of at some point
makes sense when several people have done that for reasons i don’t believe to be fair

something worth noting here
the way vulgard flames JC and seems genuinely irritated with him for feeling like he’s misrepping him is extremely different to the way he treats Marshal even though she is, from his point of view, doing more or less the same thing from her accusation of “combating min v reads”. it’s much less flamey/annoyed and instead more mild, so i think there’s partner equity here (a similar thing comes up with moonwink which i’ll talk about later)

@Hippopablompoyeetus

has anyone else mentioned a tiny bit of their role actually, i dont wanna be only anticlaim target

@Vulgard

i’ve considered softing something, though not for these reasons
there’s one aspect of my role that should be important to mention but idk if i can mention it and avoid anticlaim (depends on how strict it is)

other than the question of whether or not this is softing specifically to hippo
the last bit lends some credence to my suspicion that vulgard was focusing p hard on not getting nightkilled by mafia so i do think he’s less likely to be bussing whoever he pushes with intent to kill, since this would just get him killed faster

@Moonwink

Good morning. <3 I’m here for a moment.

@Vulgard

where is your long-lost sibling sunwink

uh
is this a thing
i think this is probably a thing
cutting off this post here cuz it’s getting long
around 80 posts left

[Moonwink]

@Moonwink

@Moonwink

I get that a lot of ‘game solvers’ don’t really know how to play D1, but most of them I think are aware that it’s nearly impossible to reliably solve the entire team D1. I think you threw the ‘1 wolf in me + Night’ take into your solve just to make your solve look more complete. However… it’s only D1. It looks more ‘try-hard’-y than anything, and not in a good way.

Furthermore, I think if you were actually serious about your solve, I think you actually would have scrutinized me more and had more to say about me in that post. :3

So, this is the main post I’m going to bring up for now, but there are others in the interaction I and JC had with Vulgard. The main point I’m going to make is that there’s no reason for me, as wolf, to scrutinize Vulgard’s solve in this way at this point in the game when I could just simply push my team to nightkill them that night if I thought they’d be a threat.

@Moonwink

@Vulgard

i honestly don’t think i’ll be able to do that today, with less than 20 posts left and the inability to be around at eod. i’m just hoping you receive more attention tomorrow and/or from other slots today.

Why didn’t I receive much of your focus today just out of curiosity? And why won’t I receive much tomorrow from you if you’re alive?

@Moonwink

@Vulgard

if i implied that, it was unintentional

i do plan to read you, but it’ll have to be tomorrow
and you didn’t receive much of my focus today, because you’re less familiar to me than most people here, and your posts haven’t stood out to me as much as the posts of several other slots (which is part of the reason why i’m calling for scrutiny on your slot)

Alright, alright.

I do feel like I’ve received some scrutiny from some slots (Nutella earlier, Night at various points in the game, Min and Illwei early D1). Min eventually turn their read around on me later on after they read my ISO earlier. I think Wisdom has been suss of me. Arete outright refused to give me a townread on me in spite of making a good point with regard to my attempts to interact with the people who he didn’t include in their readslist.

I guess I’m just confused about who you are concerned about not scrutinizing me enough? Was there anyone in particular you were worried about?

I also don’t go out of my way to push them to scrutinize me and make an actual read on me if I plan to nightkill them as scum.

[Arctic]

@alana

Some thoughts:

-it pings me that Hippo first says ‘I feel like the Squirrel wagon was set up to avoid the Arete vs Marshal thunderdome yet then shortly after attempts a cfd on Wisdom by creating a FOURTH wagon

-I feel like Bladescape knows better than to just tunnel a LHFish slot like Squirrel

-I think Squirrel’s long readslist legacy-post at EoD is unlikely to come from scum

-Wisdom’s posts about Marshal and Arete are almost TWTBAW

-Marluxion and Arctic’s feelings about the Arete lynch seem genuine

-I still don’t townread her but Millium’s posts definitely look better today

Will do my own iso of Vulgard tomorrow

wow
i agree with literally everything in this post

i’m surprised someone else had the same thought about wisdom’s posts about marshal/arete being TWTBAW lmao

@Moonwink

Howdy. <3

I’m going to explain in a moment why I’m spewed town by Vulgard’s flip in spite of them being a lost wolf. Just need to pull up some posts.

exciting
i think you are spewed mafia but i’m curious what you’ve got

[Moonwink]

Furthermore, there’s no reason for me as scum to side with JC in a JC vs Vulgard fight, especially when JC already had so much suss on him. I’d always fight JC with Vulgard in this case, because getting away with yeeting JC D1 would be so beneficial to me if I were scum. XD

[Millium]

forgive me if I say I just wont be town leaning u anytime soon

[Arctic]

the problem is there are probably 4 other wolves and vulgard became consensus town so arguing the entire wolfteam would keep a consensus town slot alive just because you asked them to read you is entirely unconvincing

less important but i’m also buying the theory that he dropped a bunch of correct wolfreads as a means of signalling which factored in to getting him killed

[Moonwink]

@Arctic

@Moonwink

Good morning. <3 I’m here for a moment.

@Vulgard

where is your long-lost sibling sunwink

uh
is this a thing
i think this is probably a thing
cutting off this post here cuz it’s getting long
around 80 posts left

What? Vulgard is a lost wolf. If I’m a wolf, I don’t know Vulgard is a wolf, nor does Vulgard know I am a wolf. How is this a thing? XD

[Arctic]

vulgard’s role says he knew who the wolves were but they didn’t know him and he wasn’t in wolf chat

[Moonwink]

No, it’s fine. XD You have valid excuses to be paranoid of me just based on past experiences. I’m trying to see what Arctic is trying to argue though.

[Millium]

derp clear denyed

[LASERpointer]

Analysis Mode: Powering On
Loading…
Loading…

I’m finally here and ready to play some mafonya~
Yesterday was just pawsitively depressing!
I’m gonnya look into the last parts of Vulgard’s iso: Analysis Pending

[Moonwink]

If Vulgard knows who the wolves are, then why does he try to make a correct, super-solvy looking post that includes most of the people in the game? XD That’s not something a lost wolf in his position would do.

[nutella]

really digging arctic’s vul spew analysis

think moonwink and alana are in pretty rough spots from it

[Millium]

honestly I have no idea how my posts are better from Alana’s POV

[LASERpointer]

What do you think a lost wolf in his position would do?
:3

[nutella]

i don’t care about this type of defense sorry

i think the fact that he didn’t actually push you very hard is a bad look (plus the potential soft arctic pointed out)