Face Your Fears (BOTC) - [2/9] - Evil Wins

Forum Games Completed
,
#1281

Yes

#1282

Is there a topic summary with nominations I can check out? Or will I have to re-look over everything lol

#1283

w

ok it’s jarek

#1284

It very well could be! We’ll see what RNG SAYS

#1285

The issue for Demon!Jarek is team building.
Jarek can easily be minion but Demon is harder.

#1286

Wait remind me why can’t it be Jarek Demon May Minion

#1287

May’s literally been trying to get Jarek killed.

1 Like
#1288

@Crazynuto
Here is the grimoire of claims, if it helps.

#1289

Prisma’s left blank but subtlety is sorta out the window, so.

#1290

If that’s the case then there’s likely already a dead minion

#1291

There’s no mechanical evidence for it to be found, since we had no information differentiating the Minion and Demon from one another.
May did redcheck Jarek with his End information, and the fact she shoved Pandora instead doesn’t mitigate that fact. It’s true Kiiruma tied May’s hands by choosing them, but May would’ve needed to justify their pings not dying and accusing Jarek would’ve been Occam’s Razor. If we assume End was a Demon bluff, it could’ve been interchangeable between them both; in which case a Minion shouldn’t take it lest they become too trusted.

#1292

no

#1293

i was poisoned one night

#1294

the minion is melanie king

#1295

Unlikely. Pandora only managed to select Tim Stoker and Melanie King, failing to select Sasha James and Martin Blackwood, due to third-party poisoning.
We know the latter Minion doesn’t exist from kill counts (specifically D2 when only you nominated and there was one kill).

The former would have to be me since I’m the only pertinent player who died N2. Excluding the faith of my word, the Demon would still need to be May/Jarek to justify the End information.

Except it can’t be the latter or else Kiiruma would’ve killed somebody with the copied End ability. So it would still be May.

…Plus, Kiiruma can’t be Melanie King because he died on a night when nobody would’ve been protected by the Buried (as you were executed that day). So the Demon would’ve missed a kill for no explainable reason. Even in that world, it still has to be May/Jarek.

1 Like
#1296

…Actually.
Pandora, does your sobriety matter at the time of killing or choosing?
I think it’s Sasha either way, but it would matter to determine whether Melanie was actually discounted or not.

#1297

uh

#1298

i think it matters at time of choosing

1 Like
#1299

because then they die whether i’m alive or not

1 Like
#1300

Nominations are open

Apologies for lack of flavour on my end, I’m rather sick - A

1 Like