FAM2 Game Thread 4 - Day 5 - The Mafia (and Italy) have won!

Oh yeah about that. We found out how that could have happened. Remember Amelia copying Epitau’s ability?

1 Like

I thought paranoid gun owner at first, especially only works if Eevee specifically picked Alice to compare my alignment but only get reactionary action in return.

But something tells me that PGO’s dont visit visitors

Mafia doesn’t bus Alice in this gamestate right? She’s really good at pushing mafia agenda and I don’t see mafia wanting her to die.

No they don’t usually.

I will say this. Zone has absolutely no reason to bus Alice here. Mafia would kneecap themselves bussing Alice. If anything, Alice busses her teammates as mafia not the other way round.

1 Like

Nightingale voted and started an counterwagon

Thing is does Night try to counterwagon someone to Alice after the Eevee kill? I think that Night would know not to try saving Alice if the two of them were w/w.

Although this hardly makes a difference

if shes a wolf she blew up eevee
shes an action stealer
not a night vig

The thing that troubles me is that if Alice is ok with sacrificing herself today, then it’s clear that she’s ok dying in order to let her partners endgame. And that is concerning to me.

I am sure we’re talking about end of Day 4 with marl execution

Oh yeah about that.

Its not even KP?

Killing Alice would still be my preference. No reason; just pure emotion.

Killing night is killing Mafia, but I assume it will lead to defeat because of I don’t think night has KP based on her willingness to sacrifice herself at EOD4.

Killing whoever else is really a shrug moment.


Never liked CRich’s flip-flop behavior, but I do think that even if he’s Mafia, the fact that he kept monologuing and dialoguing with Frost is worth a victory if he is Mafia. Regardless of what he is, I will townread him for my sanity.

/shrug moment on Outedwolf; He shot Proph (one among the 14 shots), Leafia (to death), and Nanook. IDC if he stays in POE.

/shrug moment on Italy/pigeon; Italy shot Jake (to death), shot Ranta, and shot pigeon. Pigeon shot eevee, Nanook, and Italy. Probs one Mafia within pigeon/Italy.

1 Like

I think it’s more likely Italy, mainly because he shot Gorta before the latter posted. That reeks of a wolf wanting a villager to not talk so he killed them in a haste.

Italy didn’t let Gorta talk so this is typical wolf behavior and foolish town vig

Although this is not the maf vig we’re looking for.

Ok so if Alice killed Eevee to ensure we don’t execute the vigi, who is she protecting from execution by her actions? We need to figure this out.

I know. I have been talking about it all this time.

…also, Italy noticed it as well:

Marl isnt pushing Eliza and Eliza got it easy in that high risk death boat dungeon, trying to kill me to complete the ritual so mafia get extra rolecard

I couldnt kill Eliza on that event, because this will complete the ritual (and me executed in the process)