I assume May is a good player, they fit as a respected player who could be mafia here, getting townreads for being kinda floaty without hard stances.
Katze could unironically be a wolf, they’re usually easier to townbin on D1s imo.
Opinion being split on Creature sure is interesting. If Brad is town I can see him being a wolf mad that his easy ML got cleared.
Gocj seems like a free wolf.
Bystander probably town and being pushed by wolves and skill-issuing towns right now.