So uh
The kills most likely arent gonna match what the lunatic wanted so they’ll prolly figure it out 
How does poppygrower lunatic work
“Your bluffs are Philosopher, Lunatic, and Magician”
1 Like
You can pretend the Lunatic got poppy’d/saw a Magician even if neither is actually in play
Demon still learns the Lunatic even in a PG game
1 Like
every single townsfolk role on the script can potentially, minus poppygrower and magician themselves give evil information on who their partners are
shugenja noble tc undertaker are obvious
soldier and monk can point out who isn’t on the team
general and high priestess are gamestate evaluators, and hp can do the same as all three
philo is any of these things
savant can do all three
and amnesiac could aswell.
1 Like
Sit next to me, Litten.
philo poppy is a big risk to not mess up other players abilities, and even outsiders aswell could show the evil team they’re good
This script would be better if Snake Charmer was included.
Philo poppy also means evil has to chew thru 2 poppy growers before they learn each other
What would you take out?
You could just kill the Philo directly and learn that way.
No
Then the actual PG is undrunked and blocks evil again
Magician/Poppy Grower seem redundant, so probably I’d replace one of them with Snake Charmer.
Why snake charmer of all things
The PG just stops the N1 information, I think.
The “evil wakes” reminder would still go on the dead Philosopher.
amelia is correct
1 Like
Philosopher: If the Philosopher chooses Poppy Grower, when the Philosopher dies, the Poppy Grower ability that is healthy as of the moment the Philosopher dies prevents the Philoppygrower ability from causing the Demon/Minions to learn who each other are.
2 Likes
fair
even if the evil team can find each other though, that doesnt remedy the part that i find the least fun about pg stuff
which is that
coordination and funny plans are the heart and soul of playing clocktower as evil for me and poppy grower just smashes through all that
because the evil team will probably never find each other until mid or lategame
1 Like
mhm, it changes the gimmick to “get that guy. every fiber of my body is just… kill that guy, now.”
which is fun for more detectivey types then it is for social players
apologies, and if you wish to travel in later in the game, you may
2 Likes
travellings not a bad option for me actually
are you accepting tranellers at any point in the game, or just after a certain point?