I nominate smoothbrainpepega for Best Troll: They made the town not want to play the game in SFoL 64, and their accusations against the neutral killer Alice Alard made her look towny enough that she endgamed and won.
I nominate @Geyde (with acknowledgement and mention of the involvement of @Chloe, @DatBird, @Arete, and myself), for creating Best Setup as lead designer of CFM3 (Community Forum Mafia 3 // FoL Anniversary Mash). That game was a stellar monstrosity of a project and Geyde powered through to do the core of the work on a huge, decidedly well-made game, in a very short time period.
While I think Whysper should absolutely win this award, I think orange deserves a nomination for his involvement in setting up FoLrus and listening to my complains/suggestions about site UI. Unsure if this counts since his account has moderation permissions but isnβt technically a mod (I think?)