[GAME THREAD 6/13] Risky Light Game: Featuring Rain - Day 4 - Mafia wonnered

[Aelin]

I have my meme from earlier but it’s a lot of energy to go and get it again
Anyway
Why did you ignore this part

@Professor

Two things
Aelin was also pushing Magnus yesterday
Why would pushing Magnus since Day 1 make it less likely to be a bus anyway? Like wolves often scumread each other early and make sure they don’t actually flip each other, then reap the rewards later when they actually flip after we’ve already had one or more MLs and they get even deeper

[Professor]

@Frog

There are two scenarios, but in neither scenario do you actually believe I’m anything but Town

1. You are wolf, and you have to live here
2. You are town, but you’re just annoyed at me but you recognize I am Town +99% of the time

So enough of this nonsense tbh

this is the most helpless i have ever felt in a game as a villager.

@Frog

Talk to me about Magnus plox

i got distracted and kind of lost motivation to actually write anything about the iso but i’m really confused because there’s a number of objectively wolfy things like the post where he says he has to defend himself because “apparently one vote is AI” or whatever. it seems like blatant cftwr. some of this ends up being too blatant like the vote on leafia, which I think is more likely to come from town as he’d be more concerned with justifying his vote as a wolf, depending on the player.

this is why i should have done this earlier, because i can’t tell of magnus’ lack of concern for how he comes across is because he’s town or because he is a wolf that just doesn’t care, and i should have spoken to him about this to potentially look at previous games so i could get a conclusion

most of their analysis is IIOA or sheeping peoples’ reads, both of which are mostly NAI so there is literally nothing to go by other than tone for the most part.

a couple things don’t really make sense such as how he said he didn’t mind allowing a rand between pigeon and cloned even though he said that cloned should die to resolve pigeon’s alignment (basically stealing my read… he has done this quite a lot, actually)

@Magnus

Cloned’s flip helps determine Pigeon’s alignment, which doesn’t hold up vice versa.

I’m willing to let either die here.

when he tried to explain this today

@Magnus

I didn’t want to vote Cloned because we were mainly killing him to resolve Pigeon’s alignment, and Pigeon’s claim meant Cloned would be innocent - I also didn’t outright believe Pigeon’s claim, so I was hesitant to spare him. I know these sound contradictory, so I unvoted since I was willing to let the lynch rand. Then I was repeatedly told to vote Cloned in a short period of time, and I was flustered enough to comply.

They haven’t even sheeped my read correctly here, I didn’t say they were aligned, only that cloned town meant pigeon town, it could still be v/w in the other direction so this explanation doesn’t really make sense

---

@Magnus

This makes sense, now. I’m being heavily accused for voting randomly, right before another player casts the same vote, on an already heavily voted player in a majority system. This ignores the fact that a D1 mislynch doesn’t really help Wolves, so I’d be ruining my own game as Mafia for trying this.

does a wolf really say that a d1 mislynch doesn’t help wolves? I’m thinking not.

there are a number of posts which just feel tonally town and otherwise I have no good explanation such as:

@Magnus

Just vote me and I’ll have more votes against me than you have against you. It’s not suspicious if I’m already suspicious, you could either be jumping on a bandwagon as evil or scumreading me as Town, or preserving yourself as either alignment.

()

@Magnus

I’m heavily accused for voting Leafia just before Pigeon casts a vote on Leafia, sending her to L-2 in a majority vote. In other words, I’m suspected for aligning votes seemingly randomly with another player, as if I had been communicating with someone in a Mafia chat. That thought is in the back of everyone’s minds, or at least the people suspecting me.

…I think cloned described this better than I am, but the way Magnus defends himself comes across as entitled, the tone being more like “as if I am possibly being scumread for this?” like he knows it’s wrong and thinks it is ridiculous he is being wolfread.

@Magnus

@Aelin

the last time someone started talking like this, it was seth, and he followed it up with “lets vote the host”

Are you trying to ridicule me by comparing me to Seth, thus ensuring nobody will listen to a word I have to say?

this is both incredibly witty and villagery to come up with.

@Magnus

I consider Leafia as Town atm, and I know my own alignment, so I’m willing to lynch Gorta or Eli.

Magnus seems to prioritise other’s reads over his own, only following his own reads which are compatible with others. Like, he still has individual reads on these players, but it doesn’t make sense to want to kill them more than Trochi who was the lowest on his readlist from earlier. This is probably wolf AI

@Magnus

The purpose of the debate was to determine who I would lynch between Eli and Gorta, not whether I would lynch Gorta in a vacuum.

This is kind of what I mean
He hasn’t actually pushed any of his reads in this so called “vacuum”, only in the contexts that people present to him

@Magnus

@Trochilidae

well then who would u yeet in a vacuum?

One of the weaker Towncore. I’m fine with Frog and Leafia, almost fine with Professor, so I’d want Squirrel or Illwei. I wouldn’t object if you were voted, of course.

What happened to Trochilidae - POE?

[Aelin]

Frog, I am sick, I am tired, and I am barely maintaining the strength to be here. I have read up through thread before posting, so don’t waste my time with bullshit. Thanks.

[Leafia]

You’re lucky I’ve decided to focus on Magnus today and I’ll be looking at your slot tonight to see if I can figure out why Professor townreads you so much.

[Squirrel2412]

not done catching up

at 30 minutes before eod I’m gonna give up on catching up and just skip to the most recent post

also my wim fell through the floor today; apologies for practically disappearing

---

@Trochilidae

@Squirrel2412

Trochi… I have no opinion on. I’m wary of approaching their posts tonally, which is also my primary method of reading people, but I’m also concerned that they’re ML bait.

word of advice read me by what i say not how i say it maybe? i don’t want people to just Not read me cause im fucked im the head

also its ableist my vote doesn’t count as 4

noted

will do that

---

magnus' gorta case

@Magnus

Here’s why;

@Gorta

Yes this is, also why was leafia at 5/7 votes on d1 lol

This post tells me Gorta does read the thread, but doesn’t take the time to absorb and understand everything.

@Gorta

I think I am ok with voting professor, there are so many weird things there.

@Gorta

I’ll try to generate more reads over night, but for now I’m just going to vote professor

@Gorta

/vote Professor I simply don’t like this slot

Gorta voted Professor blindly D1, without any justification or reason for doing so. Gorta publically and readily admits this, and yet doesn’t back down.

@Gorta

I’ll give y’all more tomorrow, but just give me a bit of time to get back into the FM mindset

Gorta posted this three days ago, and I’m not seeing the FM mindset.

@Gorta

and I’ll try putting reads out today, turns out being sick helped me fall back into old habits

Gorta promises to put out reads that day.

@Gorta

nice gaslighting, you should remember then that my gut reads are pretty decent. I’ll case you later, but remember my gut is pretty accurate. Often times I just make reads from feelings and my own gut and I am correct. I will case you though and I will be able to prove you are bad in one way or another.

…Then procrastinates.

@Gorta

I’m going to sleep now, but I will prove you innocent or guilty

From what I recall, Gorta did this pretty much every game I’ve played with them.

commentary:

this case is mostly arguing that gorta is reading thread but not contributing to it

which is probably NAI imo because townies can also read thread and not contribute

not really convinced and it kind of feels like magnus is going after an easy push

---

@Trochilidae

@Magnus

From what I recall, Gorta did this pretty much every game I’ve played with them.

you
you said gorta always does this
and yet
you’d vote gorta for things you just said he always does?
you said you had experience of him as a player and yet would vote him for things we know are lolgorta

no fuck this im putting my four votes here @commando /vote magnus

trochi doing my work for me

mindmelding 8 hours late lets go

---

@Magnus

The purpose of the debate was to determine who I would lynch between Eli and Gorta, not whether I would lynch Gorta in a vacuum.

but why those two? policy yeeting off of inactivity doesn’t seem viable given that we had T/T wagons yesterday that we could solve off of

also, unrelated but gorta jumping in at eod1 and arguing for a prof yeet is a good look

---

[reads through leaf/aelin argument]

felt a little bit performative reading through leaf’s response to aelin’s wall, but I’m also pretty sure that the way leaf types just registers as performative in my brain regardless

@Magnus

Gorta hasn’t even pretended to post anything substantive thus far. If you actually want Gorta to live for an extended period of time, I’m left to assume you towncore them - in which case, why? If you don’t towncore Gorta, why don’t you want to lynch them?

this is a bit of a straw man argument or some other logical fallacy idk

not wanting gorta dead isn’t the same thing as thinking gorta’s town

people can want other people yeeted more than gorta without thinking gorta’s towncore

@Professor

My view was that it was either w/w, v/v or pigeon v cloned w (pigeon w cloned v was not possible or he would have self-pressed earlier)
I clearly didn’t townread these players and so with v/v not really being considered it only made sense to kill cloned out of these two
So I even though I suggested it could be W/W, I still cared about which one went over which is why I wanted people to vote cloned
If I was a wolf and decided it was W/W, why would I not sit back and let the PR claim die?
If I was a wolf, why would I not have reserved judgement on Frog’s terrible case on Pigeon, stopped trying to push cheese and allowed Frog to take the blame for p much everything and use it to push on him today? (I think he is probably town now)

fair enough ig

I’ll have to reread that part again but I see your argument

@Professor

It is true, and by this “this site” I meant Forum of Lies. Probably not as quickly as this game, but not far off either.

this isn’t important but

what I meant is that you can’t have found leaf this early on this site since this is literally the second game on this site

but sarcasm/being overly technical aside I’ll concede the point

@Professor

i intentionally phrased this post artificially in the hope that it becomes a copypasta but i also wanted to convey a serious point. so it’s a win/win.

will probably steal it and use as a copypasta at some point i gotchu

---

@Aelin

Anyway, ahem , Squirrel saying that they thought cloned was town and thought the wagons were V/V but didn’t try to make a new wagon (despite pigeon/cloned being prominent wagons for literally the entire day)

I only thought they might be T/T at eod, since it was worrying how comfortable people were with the wagons

and I also hate CFDs in general

---

[Leafia]

I hope you get better soon.

[Aelin]

Oh, I’m lucky? I’m lucky? That the glorious Leafia has decided to hold off of analyzing my slot until I happen to get nightkilled and she goes “oh no that’s such a shame”? OH, THANK YOU GLORIOUS LEAFEON

[Aelin]

Well this is awkward
Uh
Thanks

[Aelin]

Ye someone pointed out the time being 8 mins before EoD
So like
Uh…
Idk something something you’re off the hook

[Professor]

In conclusion
I think the iso makes me lean him town slightly but I really am not confident enough to do anything about it and I dont want to be spearhead another villager elimination on someone else
If people decide they think trochi is wolfy themselves then I am perfectly happy with staying where I am, but I’m not forcing people to do anything this time around

[Professor]

I’ve learnt from cloned’s flip that if the main scummy things you find in someone’s Iso are the fact that they seem to contradict themselves on blatantly obvious things it probably doesn’t mean much

[Trochilidae]

hi i’m here now the people at work wouldn’t let me fucking GO

[Trochilidae]

where’s the most recent vc

[Trochilidae]

@Squirrel2412

this is a bit of a straw man argument or some other logical fallacy idk

not wanting gorta dead isn’t the same thing as thinking gorta’s town

people can want other people yeeted more than gorta without thinking gorta’s towncore

thank u these were my exact thoughts

@Squirrel2412

this case is mostly arguing that gorta is reading thread but not contributing to it

which is probably NAI imo because townies can also read thread and not contribute

not really convinced and it kind of feels like magnus is going after an easy push

exactly
he’s throwing shit at the wall and hoping something, anything sticks

[Trochilidae]

where the fuck is everyone it’s 30 min til EOD

[Professor]

@Aelin

Oh, I’m lucky ? I’m lucky ? That the glorious Leafia has decided to hold off of analyzing my slot until I happen to get nightkilled and she goes “oh no that’s such a shame”? OH, THANK YOU GLORIOUS LEAFEON

Aelin died last night!
Leafia: “Hmmm, that really doesn’t surprise me. I was just beginning to think that Aelin could be a villager again. I’m glad I finally read her correctly.”

[Leafia]

I know that you’re being sarcastic here and there’s no need for it.

[Leafia]

You’re welcome.

[Aelin]

It’s not a human necessity, but it’s an Aelin necessity

[Frog]

tbh, I jokingly claimed a red check and Aelin was just dead

I think Aelin is just mooding off of that tbh

Caught = negative vibes