I re-read her questioning of Atlas and concluded that she was probably genuinely trying to solve his alignment, and I don’t think her initial shade on him came from either a place of TMIing him W (based on how she responded to me bringing up points in his favor) or from a place of agenda against town!Atlas (with Leafia’s ability-to-handle-TMI I think she would struggle a lot to call a claimed PR a wolf if she had TMI on them being town – and probably would just assume the claim is real).
Arctic has a question mark because my reason to think he’s town is this:
and I think that’s >rand accurate as a read on him but I also think it’s a really stupid reason to call him town
(fwiw I think he is actually wrong about the thing where he thinks he can’t really be read off of his solving posts, I think he believes it regardless of his alignment but I don’t think it’s true, that said so far this game they could go either way)
this doesn’t really affect my read on you because you literally just repeated what Vul said about me but also it’s not outside of the range of things you might plausibly believe as a villager
okay I’d like to have it made clear that I said this before Vulgard various times, just not in a direct manor, more in a “stop ignoring my posts”, “stop taking my posts out of context” type of way instead.
I ignored some of your posts and some elements of your posts because they didn’t really affect my read on you and I largely found them unimportant (and they didn’t have, like, questions or anything).
I don’t think I took any of your posts out of context except arguably by misinterpreting your post on YBW as a scumread rather than you … randomly calling him bad, or something? I’m still a bit unclear on what that was actually intended to say
why do you think me not responding to all of your posts is alignment-indicative?
to be ABSOLUTELY CLEAR this is a question I am asking Wazza to understand Wazza’s thought processes and not a comment on how people should or should not be reading me, or even whether it actually is or isn’t alignment indicative for me to do that
if Vulgard is a wolf he’s decided that his strategy for the game is going to be to ignore all the LHFy people and just push the people who are widely believed to be “good villagers”