GOAT^2 - Game Thread (5/15) - Day 6 - Mafia wonnered

what is your read on magnus mollee
you have him at the bottom of your poe but i don’t think you ever actually talked about him

1 Like

Not been reckless enough this game. Choosing to reveal reads and poke things for me my solve in Flicker. This left as a monument to the one to be born anew tomorrow: be wrong online, it’s super informative

2 Likes

I’m almost feeling left out.

1 Like

what is your read on mollee magnus

1 Like

I haven’t personally interacted with Molly enough for a townread, and since I barely remembered her, despite her moderate activity, I assumed she was floating and set her as a scumlean. Not an “active” scumlean, so I guess “nullscum” would’ve been better.

However, I’ve gotten the memo, her contribution has not been insignificant. I wouldn’t vote Molly.

1 Like

why not

1 Like

There are a couple simple reasons.
If we execute Molly and she’s Town, we don’t really seem to learn anything?

  • Therefore, there are better info executions.

I decided to listen to Marl’s legacy, which listed Molly as likely Town.

  • Since I’m not the greatest reader, I’ve taken this to mean there are better wolf executions.
1 Like

me when somebody suggests yeeting for info on day 3

1 Like

the last post was supposed to contain a walter white gif but i messed up

2 Likes

what’s your read on eliza magnus

1 Like

I wasn’t suggesting an infoyeet, I was saying Molly seemed like a suboptimal execution.

Eliza could very well flip evil. In any case, Eliza would likely need to be flipped sooner or later. I don’t have a solid read on Eliza, but depending on her flip paths could diverge tomorrow and into the upcoming days.
Unlike with Marl, when I was fully expecting him to flip as good, I earnestly can’t tell with Eliza. Which should be indicative of something, given how the majority of the game are good. So I’m not opposed.

1 Like

i think i’ll figure out where i want to go later today but i need molly to answer my most recent question

1 Like

also i’d like everyone to post their reads

2 Likes

i already have thoughts:tm: but i want to see others’ thoughts:tm:

1 Like

wtf :tm: didn’t do :tm: for some reason

1 Like

mollylikesorigami (3): Vulgard, KingTroll, May
ElizaThePsycho (2): YoubutWorse, Zorvo
Zorvo (2): Illwei, BradLand

Not Voting (4): ElizaThePsycho, Lemonfairy, Magnus, mollylikesorigami

1 Like

Oh yeah I said I was gonna post a readlist then completely forgot lmao

Will do in a bit, gotta get ready for school

1 Like

Im typing this on mobile in a constrained time span so I am gonna try to explain my reads but Im not gonna provide any quotes or anything (not like I want to anyway)

TOWN :)
MEEEE (ybw I am so town omg ur so right YBW :D)
KT (Had an extremely towny D1 where it felt like every other post was a mindmeld. Need to do a re-eval, but I personally dont think that D1 was fakeable from memory and he has been good since then. We are never killing this until LyLo at the latest, even then I wouldnt)
Vulgard (Don’t entirely agree with all of their reads, and if there was a deepwolf this is where Id look. That being said, still very towny overall and wouldnt be something I’d kill unless every single player looks super towny and were sure theres a deep wolf. Def not dying today, and I dont think Id want them dead tomorrow either)
Zorvo (Ive said it before and Ill say it again, idk how to read seth. That being said, he seems towny and other people seem to agree with that. So right now he is very towny and prob not something Id really kill)
Molly (Honestly shes seemed p towny throughout the game, and the only reason to kill her seems to he “she must have TMI bc shes too right” which isnt a v good reason and also isnt really true unless we know the other scum. Feel like someone in her position makes the reads she has made so I think she is more likely town than not.)
Bradland (Need to look over myself a but, but doesnt seem to be in a scumgame. Vulgard linked a thing as well explaining his brad townread then I havent read over as of yet but plan to and sounds true (bars). Once Ive done that I can comfortably call Brad town I believe, but regardless he seemed decently town beforehand so Im comfy puttin him up here)
May (Was P towny day 1 from memory, kinda fell off after that. Splatoon n all that is fair, great game, but I still would like to see more overall. My weakest townread overall. Prob wouldnt kill today personally but with a strong case I could maybe be convinced)

null

Magnus (More so nullscum or scumlean, I hated his case against me as none of it made any real logicial sense and contradicted itself multiple times. Hasn’t improved a ton since then, but also isn’t actively pingy while in thread to me.)
Lemonfairy (Doesn’t provide a ton of explanation for reads, the explanation they do provide is flawed or short, like quoting a post thats easy to post as both alignments and quoting it as towny or scummy. I could see them as partners with a lot of people. If either of Illwei or Eliza are scum and the other is town, probably look here? Scumlean. )
Illwei (Has never really improved in my eyes, and even though it was a different person the slot itself D1 was very very strange and didn’t self pres onto someone who was also mafia which reads very scummy to me. Need to do a proper ISO here, but would not be suprised in the slightest if this slot was scum.)
Eliza (What can I say here that I havent said already? Awkward in thread, frozen under pressure almost immediately, explanation for reads quite literally being “idk”, flip floppy on slots according to thread consensus, gameplay very similar to Silent Hill FM. Watch out for the “Eliza is scum and heres why” movie coming to this thread in IMAX later this afternoon!)

SCUM >:(

This is my readlist, hopefully the colors worked properly. It is ranked, so the person at the bottom is the scummiest n yada yada. Hopefully this helps. Now lets see Paul Allen’s readlist.

1 Like

ok let’s kill molly
I’m clearly obv town for being dumb and wrong about Marl and she still can’t see it

but also this shows molly isn’t right on all her reads so the TMI reason doesn’t work
(idk how much weight it has when she does it after it gets pointed out though)

1 Like

YBW can be scum with molly

1 Like