GOAT^2 - Game Thread (5/15) - Day 6 - Mafia wonnered

[Magnus]

@May

But I’m willing to let that one go until Magnus flips, which I am currently to do immediately, so.

Thank you.
Better today than tomorrow. It would’ve been better days go, but at least I got to interact with the carnage, so…

[Magnus]

I still believe a vocal evil has been miscleared, hence why Vulgard and May were at the top of my first list.

[Lemonfairy]

@Magnus

You and Vulgard strongly townread each other, similarly to YBW and KT townreading each other but less overt.

KT was town though and you think the similarity makes me/Vulgard a good scumteam?

@Magnus

I don’t really think I buy this world, hence the question mark at the end of the sentence and the lack of a proper justification.

so it’s just because you scumread both me and May individually?

@Magnus

May set up Molly as a potential partner with KT (I didn’t even notice the Illwei situation), but strongly insisted on voting KT first , as if to use that as a rule to defend Molly afterward. (“Her potential partners flipped, so… ”).

this is alright, I guess

[Lemonfairy]

@Magnus

I still believe a vocal evil has been miscleared, hence why Vulgard and May were at the top of my first list.

how strongly does this belief play into your reads?
is it the main reason?

[Lemonfairy]

@May

KT and Illwei were my only noted potential partners for her. Pretty simple stuff. I think others said Molly/Magnus might be possible? But I’m willing to let that one go until Magnus flips, which I am currently to do immediately, so.

can you list all the connections you’ve made so far?
might be very helpful

[Magnus]

@Lemonfairy

KT was town though and you think the similarity makes me/Vulgard a good scumteam?

By no means do I think KT flipping wolf disqualified the possibility.

@Lemonfairy

so it’s just because you scumread both me and May individually?

I think that’s fair.
Although if you’re Town, you should look up the chains. I’m at the front of each line.

@Lemonfairy

how strongly does this belief play into your reads?
is it the main reason?

I’m pretty confident, given the nightkills of late.
Min flipped GOAT, but that seemed an unlucky accident.
Lol had no reason to be killed when he was.
Zorvo was nightkilled because he claimed GOAT.
Illwei was also a strange kill. I didn’t think he was evil, but…

Oh, wait. We can confidently analyse the D1 wagons now.

[May]

Brad’s potential partners on a backread seemed to be KT and Magnus, and that’s it for people who are alive and not dead - I didn’t get too far into my chart.

[Lemonfairy]

@Magnus

By no means do I think KT flipping wolf disqualified the possibility.

sentence did not parse
am confused

@Magnus

Although if you’re Town, you should look up the chains. I’m at the front of each line.

chains?

@Magnus

Oh, wait. We can confidently analyse the D1 wagons now.

good idea tbh

[Magnus]

@Host_Account_1

eod1 votes

O.kazo (5): Magnus, lol, Vulgard, ElizaThePsycho, mollylikesorigami
Silviu200530 (4): BradLand, Marluxion, Lemonfairy, May
Marluxion (2): YoubutWorse, KingTroll
Vulgard (2): Zorvo, O.kazo
lol (1): Silviu200530
Magnus (1): min

@Host_Account_1

EoD 2 Vote Count

Marluxion (7): ElizaThePsycho, Lemonfairy, Illwei, May, Zorvo, KingTroll, BradLand
ElizaThePsycho (3): YoubutWorse, Vulgard, Marluxion
Illwei (3): Magnus, lol, mollylikesorigami

@Host_Account_1

EoD 3 VC

ElizaThePsycho (5): YoubutWorse, Zorvo, Magnus, Illwei, KingTroll
mollylikesorigami (2): May, Lemonfairy
Magnus (2): BradLand, ElizaThePsycho

Not Voting (2): mollylikesorigami, Vulgard

@Host_Account_1

EoD4 Votecount

KingTroll (3): May, BradLand, Illwei
mollylikesorigami (1): Vulgard
BradLand (1): KingTroll
Vulgard (1): Magnus
May (1): mollylikesorigami

Not Voting (2): Lemonfairy, YoubutWorse

In light of this information… Vulgard and Molly obviously aren’t paired. I wasn’t online at EOD, but I’m wondering if Molly would ever guarantee her partner’s execution unnecessarily? Were there extenuating circumstances?

Molly is probably good.
Brad, Lemon and May were on the counterwagon. I’ll need to look at when you each voted, but it’s a suspicious pool if evils were trying to save their teammate. I don’t think both would be on this wagon, necessarily.
YBW was on a vanity wagon.

Lemon, May and Brad vote as a block for D2 again, and YBW’s voting Eliza.

Lemon and May vote as a block again for D3, Brad votes me.

May and Brad vote KT D4, Lemon no-votes.

[Lemonfairy]

@May

Brad’s potential partners on a backread seemed to be KT and Magnus, and that’s it for people who are alive and not dead - I didn’t get too far into my chart.

Brad/Magnus?

@BradLand

Trying to figure out Magnus and iso’d him because I remember his initial casing, or like dive into, of Vulgard he did start to tunnel into him, but then had a moment of seeing a positive note when he asked me about my joke reads, then proceeded to hard tunnel him immediately after.

Instead of just hard tunneling him from the word “go” he did seem to have a moment of leeway. Like I might need to see where he goes with this Vulgard read and I need to see his answer to my question about Lemon that I asked a bit ago but I might just lean the guy town for now.

@BradLand

Townread:
Marl
May
LemonFairy

Townlean:
Zorvo
Magnus

@BradLand

Townread:
Marl
KingTroll
May
Lemonfairy

Townlean:
Molly
Zorvo
Magnus
Min

[Magnus]

@Lemonfairy

sentence did not parse
am confused

…It’s fairly straightforward, though.

@Lemonfairy

chains?

The two POEs I made, the general suspicion. I’m picturing a chain, because I’m feeling trapped.

[Magnus]

@Host_Account_1

O.kazo (5): Magnus, lol, Vulgard, ElizaThePsycho, mollylikesorigami
Silviu200530 (4): BradLand, Marluxion, Lemonfairy, May

Wait. I misplaced Molly and May.

[Host_Account_1]

Magnus (2): Vulgard, May

Not Voting (5): BradLand, Lemonfairy, Magnus, mollylikesorigami, YoubutWorse

Day ends 2022-10-04T22:00:00Z

[Magnus]

I’m going to look at May’s D1.

[Lemonfairy]

Brad did say initially that both O.kazo and Illwei’s slot were good wagons but hard TR’d Illwei after they subbed in so yes

[Magnus]

@May

VOTE: Silviu

@May

I dropped that last-minute Silviu vote because I genuinely thought O kazo was town - the wagon on him had played out identically to the time we MLed him in Flicker, and if I am one thing, it’s obsessed with continual self-improvement to an exaggerated degree! That’s my bad. I was overcompensating for what I saw as my mistake in Flicker. I also just thought the wagon was boring and uninformative, and I’m not used to D1s without last-minute flashwagons… I think every game I’ve played here has had one.

I suppose it’s up to you to decide whether you believe this.

[Lemonfairy]

hmmm

[Lemonfairy]

kind of want to see where molly/YBW/Brad are at

[Magnus]

Hey May, why did you vote Silviu at the very last second, even knowing with the votes 5-3 O.kazo would go anyway? Was it just a stand against the storm?

I don’t think w!May has any need to draw such attention to themselves?

[Lemonfairy]

why don’t you ask me the same question?