GOAT^2 - Game Thread (5/15) - Day 6 - Mafia wonnered

[min]

Both mark and magnus liking the post eliza made unironically makes me paranoid of that pair being w/v

[min]

mark

[Silviu200530]

Mark Suckerberg? Where? I heard his revenue got cut severely!

[Marluxion]

@min

K thx for finding wolves

[Silviu200530]

@min

Why do you think she hasn’t been stepping up her game then?

Previously I have mentioned that she lacks content. I am seeing it right now. And of course I don’t mind her fluff, she’s funny. But I don’t want to run into the same dilemma on valo mafia where it’s hard to distinguish her alignment.

@min

I’m pretty sure he’s meming if you read the argument he’s making but. Idk

Getting wooshed by lol!?!?!?!? Predictable??? I mean, sometimes I look at their comment and can’t tell if they’re joking, humor is just not for me apparently.

[Silviu200530]

Nothing it’s worse than to get hammered by freaking mafia eliza. Kadong

[Lemonfairy]

spoilered catch up

@May

Hello, everyone!

tone is the same as what I saw before (was town before) but I honestly can’t really tell
don’t think it’s AI

@min

Anyway: something tells me to feel uncomfortable about May voting someone for “wasting their posts”

Yes. Even if it’s level 0. Don’t like it. >_>

I still have a shadow from scum!SK
this is ok, ig

@Magnus

I was going to open with a statistics post, damn you.

very weak unaligned (unsure)

@KingTroll

anyway I can do with twenty posts what your standard Mafia player can do with two hundred

towny overconfidence? probably more NAI

@Magnus

By the way, I dare to call YBW’s opening post NAI. Everyone knows she spent the last hour prior to daystart typing it up on a whim to look towny, and going to that extra effort legitimately has a bad look. Nullscum, for sure. I dare to disagree.

contradiction
you say it’s NAI first then say it’s a bad look

@May

I would say that I’m not better than my neighbors, honestly. I haven’t really done proper interaction with the game - and, of course, that’s largely just because there’s very little to interact with right now. I think my tone is town me, but that’s coming from an incredibly biased source, and it’s not like you (well, anyone, really) know much about what mafia me looks like.

this is fair

@BradLand

Somebody die already.

I like this tbh

@YoubutWorse

My neighbors in number order are eliza and molly. Eliza I’m better than bc I found out I was trans before her AND I’m better than splatoon than her. (game-wise I remember getting a small meh feeling from her earlier but don’t remember my exact reasoning)

Molly posted once and also has a baller PFP but my opening post is way cooler and also my pfp could beat up her pfp (sorry amity)

joking response to Magnus
feels like it contrasts with May’s more serious take (and looks slightly worse because of that)

@Zorvo

I wanna say this ain’t W/W.

you’re right

@Zorvo

The Pre-Typed Post is exactly NAI so I disagree.

Zorvo feels town

@mollylikesorigami

@Zorvo – can you explain your brad read any more than you have here?

ok post for a second post

@Zorvo

As it stands right now my reads are not that strong I think things will become more clear to me later.
Those are GTH Town Reads though mainly from vibes, Gamestate and posts.

fair

@mollylikesorigami

i was under the impression that the brad read was just for that one post but apparently it might be for more?

was your brad read based on more than his eliza townread being a joke?

@mollylikesorigami

the part about forgetting why she felt meh about you

it’s the kind of thing where it’s not hard for a wolf to do, just… awkward lol

this is fine

@YoubutWorse

I think it was just bc it wa smainly a vibe thing, like I just thought she felt awkward in thread overall at the start, not that thats entirely AI tho. It’s why I switched my vote to her a while back

this is ok too ig

@May

I’m… not sure how I feel about these reads, looking back at them. Open question for everyone: presume Zorvo is a wolf. Why would he make these reads, do you think that list contains one of his scumbuddies, and if so, who? Yes, I know there’s not much to go off of, but we’re making something out of nothing here. Let’s go.

it doesn’t look like a wolf
idk who the scumbuddy would be if it was from a wolf… maybe Brad (the Brad also is joking feels kind of awkward)
could also be YBW because they weren’t quoted but got a read (potential distance)
both are reachy reasons on my end but hey, I participated in this thinking exercise

@mollylikesorigami

beyond that i feel like i’m reading tea leaves

100%

@BradLand

If he was a wolf I think he’d end up hard pushing right out the gate and wouldn’t throw townleans like that.

Let’s say it’s hypothetically he’s a wolf, YBW just based on the fact that literally nothing was said about her and he gave a lean.

think this is towny

@Marluxion

Minimal thoughts, head empty

this is a mood

@May

Brad because he notes that “ just like Vulgard’s joke , Brad is also joking” - that feels phrased in a way that would tie scum to town.

oh what
I didn’t think that far

@May

I will note that I did just play a game with Zorvo where he tunneled right out the gate as town

it’s definitely a switch up
could be meta change b/c post restriction too though

@O.kazo

I’m mafia with you.

can see it from O.kazo as either alignment

@ElizaThePsycho

good for you

kind of awkward response
looks unaligned (a little towny for Eliza)

@Marluxion

Don’t care for worse or brad, either or both could be hits

May also just immediately obvious v from that last post

I want to say this is town

@Zorvo

I’m actually not going to call this one not W/W cause I can see O.Kazo maybe doing this as a wolf lol.

yeah, idk May’s right that this is feels different but it looks like Zorvo is jumping to solving
I think it looks good

@Marluxion

Vulgards brain is following a natural village course so far this game

how?
more details pls?

@May

Basically, if Zorvo is wolf, probably a wolf in Brad/Vulgard. If Brad is wolf, probably at maximum one wolf in Zorvo/YBW, but those two easily could be V/V. All very early, subject to change.

I don’t really get it.

@May

I’m trying to get better at noting and phrasing my early connective reads as to not have a repeat of the Flicker game, where I appeared to have no follow-up on my “information votes” because I just… didn’t mention it.

tbh I might just sheep you if I get lost
no pressure

@Marluxion

If you all start counting I’m going to just add random numbers to the bottom of my posts to give you anxiety

this is funny
NAI though

@mollylikesorigami

it has a specific note of trying to… get on his side? idk something like that, that’s unnecessary to do as w/w

towny thoughts?

@BradLand

You’re not the boss of me.

weak unaligned read
tbh I don’t really remember the unaligned reads I throw out

@May

Preflip connections are my lifeblood. I’ll admit that these are quite weak and normally not the thing I’d note aloud this early, but I’m trying to be more transparent with the sources of my reads, and also this game desperately needed some kind of push to make analysis actually possible. Zorvo’s reads were the first thing I thought to push.

never seen May’s scumgame but I want to say this is town

@BradLand

Not with that attitude.

lol
but NAI

@May

You know, every time people start marking me town for my usual behavior, I think about how easy it would be to replicate as scum.

I’m scared

@YoubutWorse

oh hi silviu

kind of awkward
want to call it not aligned

@YoubutWorse

How strong do you feel your read list is Brad? What caused you to include each person?

no ping? no quote? (for Brad)
feels like an abrupt switch idk

@lol

VOTE: min

@lol

idk if this is a copypasta but this is very wolfy
we have 150 posts not 50 lol
VOTE: May

lol is bold and not holding back
uh idk how to read it b/c I feel like it can be done by scum too and is probably NAI
not joking around probably look good?

@Silviu200530

I suppose I’ll just follow it up with being productive so this comment doesn’t go to waste.

Silviu has a lot of general advice/meta in this post
it’s helpful, ig but idk, I’d rather see responses to posts

@lol

why are people pretending to be this affected by the postcap lol 12 hours later u will forget it existed

73/150

lol

@Zorvo

I do want to bring up that my Lemon/King never W/W is allot more stronger then the Lol/Marluxion

fair

@Zorvo

I solve in my own way.

response is more high-strung than what I expected
but I can also see this from a genuinely offended town too

@Marluxion

you’re

while I like good grammar, this feels quite passive-aggressive
not aligned

@lol

please pick up on basic reading comprehension

not aligned

@Marluxion

preeeetty sure i have two wolves

who?

@Marluxion

i’m the third

not big on the openwolfing
oh well

@lol

guys marluxion and lol is actually w/w they are joking about being mafia together

ugh
don’t like this

@Magnus

Unpaired with YBW, as wolf trying to microread something as Town because… it’s handwritten?

fair

@Magnus

Vulgard was really critical entering Kaguya-sama, questioning people about everything and writing really long posts. Since that isn’t happening here, I’m vibe-reading Vulgard as a bad one.

think Magnus ISO-ing this early is towny

@Magnus

I have a personal objective, something I want to happen that’s known only to me. Unrelated to my wincon. I will explain to you all once this condition succeeds or fails.

um what

@Vulgard

Even from the POV of you wanting to preflip me for some reason, this doesn’t make much sense. Two people disagreeing on a read doesn’t make them unaligned. I’m not sure what you’re doing here.

@Vulgard

If this objective of yours involves “reading” me by preflipping me with other players and unaligning me based on surface-level interactions, then I’d rather you explain what you’re doing right now, because this ain’t it.

unaligned w/ Magnus
kind of think response is towny

@O.kazo

Obligatory OMGUS
VOTE: Vulgard

Also except Neon, the ones who called out my disapparances last game were all scum.

don’t really like this
I don’t think it’s that scummy either though b/c it’s O.kazo

@Magnus

A villager doesn’t need to make the effort to act town in their opening post; they can do that later. But a wolf can’t afford not to look town, even from the beginning of the game. That was my point.

fair tbh

@Magnus

The game has been slow, so I’m trying to shake a few hornet nests. Part of that is a surface “hey, Vulgard’s acting differently, I wonder why?” and examining your behaviour through that lens, when I’m sure the context explains the change. I hold no attachment to any early reads, and I never even voted you.

want to call this town

I’ll stop commenting as much because this is taking forever
might just skim through the rest (now at post #233)

[Silviu200530]

You know what. A for effort

[Silviu200530]

Man… everything I posted has been liked by monsieur trollo. Pocket attempt acknowledged!

[Lemonfairy]

@Marluxion

ybw’s posts have weird energy like they have something to prove

ye

@Vulgard

This seems villagery.

how?

@Vulgard

thanks

you’re welcome

[Lemonfairy]

who are you saying this to?
me?

[KingTroll]

oh this will only be my twentieth post. ama I can go full wild

[YoubutWorse]

@Lemonfairy

Zorvo feels town

I feel like scum or town can come up with that conclusion. What specifically makes you think it’s town?

[Lemonfairy]

let me just post the reads I’m not sure on because idk

May
Vulgard/Zorvo
Magnus/Marl

molly/Brad
Eliza/Troll

null
O.kazo/Silviu/min

lol/YBW

[Lemonfairy]

@YoubutWorse

I feel like scum or town can come up with that conclusion. What specifically makes you think it’s town?

it wasn’t that particular conclusion that made me think they’re town but an amalgamation of thoughts on all of their posts
specifically, I see from the posts an overall attempt at solving that I think it more towny than not

[min]

Why ybw woof?

[min]

Oh

[Lemonfairy]

this is just a lot of words for
vibes

[min]

Wait no

Yeah why do u woofread ybw? I don’t think she been too bad

[YoubutWorse]

oh ok I misunderstood and thought you were calling that specific quote towny