not today
that’s impossible
i can try to contribute to do it later but
why do you think it is?
Ah wait, I get it. You had the initial theory that 1 out of the 4 would be mafia, and you’re not sticking to it (?) because Zone’s not one of the four and it’s actually Frostwolf?
btw unrelated but for these kinds of RVS wagons, isn’t the likelihood of being wolf usually different depending on when they joined the wagon?
You ignored this @Mistyx
An hesitation read that are you A)Questioning yo get a better understanding of Magnus and learn why others toen read them or B)Trying to make it look odd Magnus is high like he shouldn’t be for some reason.
If you said B, that would contradict the “hesitation” and it becomes a direct suspicion.
However I’m not sure if A makes sense.
This is their reasoning.
This is your counter reason.
But you didn’t follow up on their reason.
because it’s a pointless question
Wait so they are disregarding the following:
“Least one of them is a wolf but probably just one”
Then why did Neon bother even saying it?
Can you not give me a confident level of the read?
confident enough that i don’t want her killed today?
i really don’t think this matters at all
If ima do a GTH solve, ima definitely have Neon and Mist there but it’s still early game.
It matters to see if you’re being genuine or faking.
okay
if i said it was nulltown how would that affect your read on me?
if i said it was a townlean how would that affect your read on me?
in detail please
If you said Lean Town it would be a lie.
ah ok, the gamestate reads
hmm tbh I don’t personally solve that way, but I don’t think there’s harm in trying, and from the way he explained it, it does kinda make sense
I think it’s mostly just an approximation (esp because not everyone has a full readlist) anyways, but what I’m getting is that if most people think a player is town, but some people don’t, it’s kinda like when a player is towncored and prob for good reason and prob town for real, and 0-some scumreads floating around are likelier to be a) mafia trying to make a crack in the consensus towncore and b) people with less agreeable reads?
and 0 is less optimal than some, because mafia usually don’t want an iron-tight towncore, so should maybe protest against those placements
something like that
imo it’s nice that there’s new and unconventional ways of solving!
I think I would maybe? agree if that’s the only thing he focuses on the whole day, but I feel like it’s just meant to be one thing he’s trying out, and it’s a positive thing to be trying out new ways of trying to read players
1 Like
This sentence clearly indicated your read isn’t exactly that strong much at all.
It’s a read only dependant on one thing, this:
why are you acting like you know how my reads work?
Well I know what you have said, cause you post it! 
sure but that’s not what you said
i don’t think i’m interested in continuing this conversation
I mean it is what I said, as I explained in detail but ok, I’ll change the subject to a different conversation
Uhh that’s kinda convoluted, I didn’t follow that line of reasoning
I just ignored the “least one of them” part, since they changed it in the second half of the sentence basically
I’m mostly taking your summary about the 1/4, and then asking if they’re taking that back with the “No, that’s not what that said at all”…
Actually, I’m also confused XD
What do you think about the last part of my post that you haven’t responded to, like the main subject part, the part where I talked about your Magnus “Hesitation”
Do you have any follow up? What do you think about Lissi’s read on Magnus now that you know it fully in detail?