Ice Cream Mafia - Day 2 (12/14)

[Zone_Q11]

What use is pinging the people who have yet to read 24 hours worth of posts?

Likewise, what use is waiting for people who have yet to start playing?

[tutuu]

I would urge for more votes on Hippo. I would highly prefer Hippo chopped over Chomps at the moment

[potatocat]

@tutuu

I would urge for more votes on Hippo. I would highly prefer Hippo chopped over Chomps at the moment

Why?

[Zone_Q11]

@potatocat, please respond to this.
(In particular the last paragraph.)

[potatocat]

I didn’t say I wouldn’t become Chocolate if people agreed I was in the pool. And they have. So I will.

I don’t wolfread jail.

[Frostwolf103]

@Leafia

@Leafia

@potatocat

Jail wasnt suspected so there’s no reason for him to say the entire thread is villagery as a wolf imo. Unless he wants to secure townreads on his teammates. Maybe he could be a wolf with tutuu.

This suspicion is something that I’m finding to be villagery.

You mean this?

Yep

@Leafia

Just because I found the suspicion villagery doesn’t mean that I’m wolfreading Jail. It just means I find the fact that they’re suspicious of him villagery because I think a wolf would be less likely to voice that suspicion.

I see, I am not saying I suspect you…you are in agreement with potatocat, you would have some thoughts that melded together in that regard.

[tutuu]

I want to consider Chomp’s behavior and think if he could be town. I’m a big opponent of punishing people. I don’t like punitive decisions in mafia, I like rehabilitative. I want to combat my bias. I don’t want to give into my annoyance into dictating my decisions. I am frustrated and shocked at Chomp’s behavior, but just saying “Ok we will policy chop you for that” is close minded. He could still be mafia but I would like us to think about it carefully and try to work with him if he’s town

[potatocat]

@tutuu

I want to consider Chomp’s behavior and think if he could be town. I’m a big opponent of punishing people. I don’t like punitive decisions in mafia, I like rehabilitative. I want to combat my bias. I don’t want to give into my annoyance into dictating my decisions. I am frustrated and shocked at Chomp’s behavior, but just saying “Ok we will policy chop you for that” is close minded. He could still be mafia but I would like us to think about it carefully and try to work with him if he’s town

I like chopping wolves in mafia. If there’s any reason to think Chomps is town, then I’ll move my vote. But if it’s just so you can feel like you’re not “punishing” them then I don’t want to move it.

[tutuu]

The reason to think he could be town is his explosion. Completely disregarding the explosion is punishing him

[potatocat]

@tutuu

The reason to think he could be town is his explosion. Completely disregarding the explosion is punishing him

Which is why I asked you what makes the “explosion” towny. What makes it towny? Do you have evidence Chomps wouldnt do it as a wolf?

[Frostwolf103]

@tutuu

I would urge for more votes on Hippo. I would highly prefer Hippo chopped over Chomps at the moment

I am leaning towards Hippo, I made it clear in one of the posts myself.

[tutuu]

It’s always towny by default, you get entitlement to be townread as town. It can be faked, but you need to decide to fake it. By default its truthful

I don’t have evidence one way or another. Me not having evidence doesn’t mean that the correct move always is to disregard it. It could be, we don’t know his alignment, but we don’t know that

What I can try to do is consider how genuine he sounds, and consider how likely would decide to try doing this as mafia. I don’t really know, I haven’t started thinking about it too much yet

[Zone_Q11]

@potatocat

I don’t wolfread jail.

@Leafia

@Zone_Q11

Leafia, please just tell me this quickly: Did you scumread jail in that post? Yes or no.

No I didn’t.

Thank you two.

Now then @Frostwolf103, as I was saying… is there still any “negatives” on keeping jail on the Chocolate list?

[Chomps]

[tutuu]

I’m not saying that what Chomps did is always 100% town

I just now have a reason to potentially townread Chomps for, and before I didn’t have any

[Chomps]

i didn’t notice i was getting heated i always take intwrnet things as more silly and less serious anyways gaming

[potatocat]

He didn’t seem that entitled to being townread to me. It just looked like he was trying to convince us to stop caring about his meta. It feels pretty easy to fake. If you have a good explanation for why it couldn’t be and a good case on somebody else then I’ll consider changing vote. But I think you’re just changing vote for the sake of changing it right now.

[tutuu]

I’m happy with my Hippo case

[potatocat]

What is it?

[potatocat]

@I_like_posts What’s the other strategy you were talking about earlier?