Ice Cream Mafia - Night 4 (7/14)

[potatocat]

Villagery

Jail unless CCed
Frost
Zone
Cameron
Creature
Magnus
ILP
Leafia
Chomps

Wolfy

[Frostwolf103]

@potatocat

If Jail was vanillaized then it doesn’t matter if everybody else stays vanilla or not.

This makes a good point, this raise a question from Leafia that why only two players need to be flavored as non-vanilla unless he doesn’t want anyone to interfere with the night voting.

Do you have seen the jail’s D3 posts however?

[Camilleon15]

i’m sin

[jail]

@I_like_posts

@frostwolf103 who do you want wagons on?

@Frostwolf103

I actually want to open a wagon on you actually.

frost is never wolf btw

[jail]

town - jail frost

now we continue

[potatocat]

I’m reading Leafia and she might just be town. Idk. I still don’t like people giving Leafia credit for pushing a wolf on d1.

@Leafia

@Creature

I thought about everyone announcing whether they’re going vanilla, chocolate or strawberry tonight.

I feel this is a slightly wolfy popin. VOTE: Creature

@Creature

Looks like Leafia and I are gonna tunnel each other again.

@Leafia

Hmmm, this feels like a villagery thing to reply with.

@Leafia

I’d suggest that the neopolitan check Creature tonight. I_like_posts would be acceptable too. If I’m the neopolitan, I’ll be checking one of them.

This is a weird interaction and idk what to think of it really.

@Leafia

No. Build a case first and you and Potatocat both feel like villagers to me anyway.

This feels like it could be tmi to me. I think Leafia and Chomps aren’t a team.

@Leafia

Interesting thought process. I’ll bite This slot could use more pressure anyway.

VOTE: I_like_posts

@Leafia

That’s enough pressure for I_like_posts for now.

This feels weird. It could be paired with ILP.

@Leafia

Something to think about at least, although my gut is telling me that Chomps is a villager.

@tutuu

I struggle to read Creature,

Me too but he feels just like he did last game honestly, and he was a villager that game. Not too confident on him being a villager this game though but I’m willing to look elsewhere for wolves for the time being.

This doesn’t feel like it’s paired with Chomps or Creature.

@Leafia

Hmmm, tempted to agree with you there honestly. VOTE: Hippo It deserves a pressure vote at least.

This is why I think Leafia is wolfy. It feels like she’s trying to get credit for starting a wagon that she said was a pressure vote.

@Leafia

Hippo I can certainly see but you’d have to convince me on Cbomps. Henacts just like this almost every game. I’ve only seen him as a wolf once or twice though.

@tutuu

I have no opinion on Magnus. I can’t read their purposefully convoluted posts. Otherwise I think they’re just fine. “Just fine” is a bit scary from Magnus, who is a scary wolf. So perhaps it is adequate to expect more out of Magnus than “just be fine”

Magnus scares me a bit. They’re a very skilled wolf after all. As for Hippo, it almost feels pike he’s in antispew right now. Anyone else getting that impression?

She was confident on Hippo really early and it feels weird.

@Leafia

@tutuu

I would urge for more votes on Hippo. I would highly prefer Hippo chopped over Chomps at the moment

Same here.

It feels like she was sheeping other people and trying to look like she was starting the pushing on Hippo at the same time. It’s not villagery.

@Leafia

I still think Hippo is more likely to be a wolf. I say let Chomps live for a day or two at least. Even better, let the neopolitan check him tonight. I personally think that would be best.

This being paired with both Hippo and Chomps would be weird.

@Leafia

He did just ask a mafia member. You.

@Leafia

I don’t like how much Camille is defending Hippo right now to be honest.

@Leafia

Yup. You just haven’t been very villagery at a L l. You’ve hardly been here all game.

@Leafia

I am now 100% convinced that you’re a wolf Hippo. I can’t ever see you being town. This just isn’t t/You.

@Leafia

Translation: Yup. I’m a wolf. Awooooo!

When she was saying this, Hippo was already top wagon. It didn’t do that much.

@Leafia

Jail, Hippo isn’t like this as a villager. Trust me on this. You won’t be disappointed. I’m 100% certain that Hippo is a wolf here. No villager plays like the way he has been playing. Someone voting Chomps switch to Hippo. Please. I don’t want his wolfmates to be able to save him here.

I feel like Leafia wouldnt say this if she was a wolf and Chomps was also a wolf.

@Leafia

Well, my check was either a red on Magnus or a green on Frostwolf

@Leafia

Town

Leafia
Frostwolf

@Leafia

Yeah. You’re probably correct Frostwolf. VOTE: Childe

Leafia says she trusts Frostwolf alot here.

@Leafia

@Zone_Q11

FWIW, I am at a point where I’m starting to consider playing without Neapolitan by pinging everyone to get “the real Neapolitan” to counterclaim you.

DO NOT DO THIS! FOR THE LOVE OF ALL THAT IS HOLY, DON’T DO THIS!

This is actually pretty villagery. Leafia got really opinionated about this.

@Leafia

Magnus just mindmelded with me here. Move Frost into my townreads and Magnus can go into null. Maybe even a slim townlean Frost was a townlean and Magnus was a scumlean for me SoD 2 which I was hiding to provide cover for the cop.

It’s weird that she says Frost is being moved into her townreads when she says she trusted him a lot.

@Leafia

Also, I lowkey think the wolves likely killed Tutuu pver Zone or me because they wanted to frame Frost. They probably thought we’d look at how Tutuu wanted Frost dead and thought we’d think Frost is a wolf due to that if Tutuu died. That’s my guess anyway.

This is a weird theory. And it feels like it could be some kind of tmi. Idk on what exactly though.

@Leafia

I was already townleaning Frost by EoD 2 and I just think he’s more likely to be town. He helped out withbthe Hippo execution and he feels more like a villager worried that we might be going down the wrong path than a wolf that wants to shake things up. Also, I’m not sure a wolf would’ve defended Childe the way Frost did.

@Leafia

Fair enough. Then let’s have Potatocat/Frost wagons and see where that takes us.

It’s really weird that Leafia suggests a wagon on Frost here. And somebody who I know is a villager. It feels like she’s pushing agenda.

@Leafia

Hmmm, good point. Creature/Potatocat wagons then. That seems a bit more teasonable to me.

And she backs off from it as soon as somebody challenges her. Which is weird.

Overall I’m torn on Leafia here. But I don’t think she should be anybody’s top town right now.

[jail]

actually nah

idgaf if town or not i refuse to engage if thats how literally everyone is going to engage with me based on my reads

maybe if you can talk to me normally ill respond. byebye

frost is never wolf imo. his pov is clearly from a villager perspective. sentences like those are simply things mafia doesnt say

[potatocat]

I wasn’t trying to coast yesterday or anything. I just was busy during the earlier part of the day and there was a hammer. I don’t think it’s fair to say I didn’t put in enough effort when there was a hammer. I was planning to talk more later.

[jail]

nah

[jail]

yeah thats why i changed my mind

[Frostwolf103]

@potatocat

This is a weird interaction and idk what to think of it really.

I believed it’s from past interactions they are at each other odds, if you know what I mean?

[Frostwolf103]

Previous games.

[potatocat]

I don’t want to use meta too much here. I’m not talking about that. I’m talking about how Leafia voted Creature and then immediately unvoted him as soon as he said something else. And asked for him to be neopolitan checked. I think that it’s a weird turnaround. But idk if it’s paired or unpaired.

[jail]

i figured it also does make sense because i havent been able to open thread at the most convenient times so my time is extremely skewed and my lack of realtiming explains why i dont understand some things. but i do wanna help.

my first look is cam based off of childe’s v flip but there was a group of posts that cam posted today that felt super pure when i first read it. unsure though

i wanna relook at tutuu and chomps today when i get the chance to just so i can be confident theyre town and im not going crazy into the lock town never rescindo confirmation bias yet. but esp with childe flip thats also why ive been wanting to like properly relook for myself lol

[potatocat]

@jail

i wanna relook at tutuu and chomps today when i get the chance to just so i can be confident theyre town and im not going crazy into the lock town never rescindo confirmation bias yet. but esp with childe flip thats also why ive been wanting to like properly relook for myself lol

Why do you think Chomps is lock town?

[Frostwolf103]

@jail

my first look is cam based off of childe’s v flip but there was a group of posts that cam posted today that felt super pure when i first read it. unsure though

My thought exactly, I believe camilleon15 can have a pass today.

[jail]

@potatocat

Why do you think Chomps is lock town?

literally where in that post did i say that

[jail]

i townread them but i dont lock town them. im trying to prevent myself from doing that

[potatocat]

Well you said that Chomps will be lock town if you reread him. It’s the same thing. Why do you townread Chomps?

[jail]

@potatocat

Well you said that Chomps will be lock town if you reread him. It’s the same thing.

no i didnt lol