I mean only one mafia would CC and it’s optimally +EV to pick a Goon over your Roleblocker.
You only need one maybe 2 moving roles like Doctor or Tracker.
Which is why I noted them as good for this scenario, yes.
I get your point but I don’t think it’s necessary to go full out CC when you only have 3 wolves.
I agree having one or two is good.
But not three and it’s better to avoid a Cop.
Like if you had a choice between Cop or Tracker you obviously choose Tracker.
If you had a choice between Jailkeeper or Doctor you obviously choose Doctor.
Like give town the weaker roles.
Without a single wolf fighting for spot of PR, you get 3 confirmed towns.
Is it simpler approach? Yes.
Easier to pick and understand? Also yes.
You just pick weak roles like IC, tracker.
Is it beneficial to have town have 3 confirmed town at the start?
Hell no.
1 Like
PR’s don’t out themselves day 1.
You CC accordingly to the scenario.
I am going to say that what is weaker depends on strategy.
Tracker is weaker than cop ONLY if you plan to hide.
However tracker as a role can be confirmed by knowing where this doctor would go. Cop cannot.
Tho Tracker is relatively weak in both strategies.
I just made a hilarous observation that, even if all the power roles claimed d1, if a wolf claims a power role, you have a wolf in a pool of three other power roles and it’s not a simple 1f1
that’s hilarous
1 Like
That’s the point.
1 Like
Your right.
However, A wolf would have to claim a PR that isn’t in the game.
1 Like
and
1 Like
and?
2 Likes
they dont out d1 they out when they can mechlock the game
1 Like
You can still CC a Tracker and a Doctor the same way you can CC a Cop and a Jailkeeper.
But there is role power that makes the difference.
1 Like
what a hilarous setup lmao
1 Like
Thing is - they can’t claim PR if town has like IC, Hunter and Bartender.
Roles which are on weaker side of this setup.
Cause IC reveals, Bartender confirms with message. Lynch hunter and kill wolf. Nice 1f1 exchange.
So picks heavily depend on which strategy wolfs want to pick.
2 Likes
They can with Hunter but it’s very dependent on when they do it and who the Hunter is.
So what I’m saying is - unless you have very bad wolf team, you don’t want to pick weakest roles. Cause while they don’t bring much to game, they are also self-confiramble.
But they can’t CC the Hunter if they are the only PR left.
They have to CC PR when all PR’s are alive.
Should I mention this is a signup thread and not a pre-game setup discussion thread?