Mafia: Trials and Tribulations [Thread 1 - DO NOT POST]

[Silviu200530]

@Prophylaxis

Apprentice

Why apprentice so high up?

[Frostwolf103]

You likely get the answer next day

[Prophylaxis]

Think he’s genuinely interested in solving the game

My only qualm with him so far is that he hasn’t been super active and not around to real-time, but I’ve been fine with all of his posts.

---

I guess I’d be interested in a Litten(Italy/Babel) counterwagons for Today? I think knowing Litten’s alignment for certain would be quite a boon.

[Millium]

That is true

[Millium]

Wait lucky is locked into a claim as well?

[Millium]

Such a boring way to play

/vote Italy

@Host_Account_3

[Prophylaxis]

If we’re taking Marl’s claim at face value, then the focus of our discussion should be which two players we should run up to tie in order to get off his ability

Then we should tie the two people we agree on like, 5 minutes prior to deadline? And treat anyone who moves their vote/interrupts the tie at that time to be a wolfclaim?

Honestly this plan seems so vulnerable to mishaps I wonder if it’s even viable, lol.

[Frostwolf103]

We have like 4 hours and half left

[Kiiruma]

It’s vulnerable but if we plan in advance it should be fine I think. I wish you weren’t locking Lucky and Leafia away today but I have no strong objections to your PoE, having them as nulls myself.

[Prophylaxis]

@Millium

Wait lucky is locked into a claim as well?

@Lucky

My only ability is guess the execution during the night and have it be right the following day to activate my effect.
Me out of all players get a role like that.

.

[Silviu200530]

@Prophylaxis

Think he’s genuinely interested in solving the game

Do you mean these posts? To name a few

Mafia: Trials and Tribulations - Day 1 (17/17)

actually this super townie post being town who was town last game and wants to be aware of someone who grossly misread them from specchat makes sense and wolf here probably never has a thought pattern that leads to making this post big town energy

Mafia: Trials and Tribulations - Day 1 (17/17)

no I don’t have thoughts on Leafia’s alignment. I can’t read them well since I find them to be an incredibly illogical player so I usually just try to solve them through interaction

Mafia: Trials and Tribulations - Day 1 (17/17)

ohhh that’s what you meant by soapboxing mb although I will say I think reads predicated on “would a wolf do this” are inherently very useful. A wolf does not have the same mindset as town and this shows in a lot of ways. In what ways do you disagree with what I posted?

Mafia: Trials and Tribulations - Day 1 (17/17)

Can you explain some of these? Like I think there are plenty of reasons for millium to make that post as a wolf. I simply think that a wolf wouldn’t actually be in a mindset where they even think to make a post like that it’s not a high level post or anything but I do think it’s one a wolf is unlikely to make

Mafia: Trials and Tribulations - Day 1 (17/17)

They didn’t attempt to do it in response to a scumread though (in which case I’d agree with you) and I think that a townie being preemptively upset at someone for not being able to read them correctly is much more likely than a wolf attempting to discredit italy’s slot. especially the way it was handled didn’t seem like an attempt to discredit I guess what I’m trying to get at is I think a wolf posting in thread early and trying to fit in doesn’t just simply have that thought come to them with …

• Okay the first read is developed to have a reason that’s nice.
• Leafia meta-read
• Meta-read how wolves are different from towns mentally theory.
• M-T argued that Apprentice’s posts sounded artificial and Apprentice basically wants to question M-T more.

[Kiiruma]

I did not even realise that was his claim.

All I can say is ick. As it encourages people to vote his target and also seems in contrast to Marl’s role. And mine.

[Atlas]

i left for four hours why did y’all start tearing eachother apart

[Silviu200530]

Okay from the ISO I can see your point of why you think him having interest in the game is valuable enough.

[Kiiruma]

I came online

[Silviu200530]

Though I don’t think apprentice should get much trust later on because from these posts are literally meta-reads or initial thoughts early in the Day.

[Atlas]

also
the whole marl claim is eh?
it doesn’t really mean anything unless proven and even then its not 100%

[Silviu200530]

Oh hello Dahlia/Luke Atmey/Rookie Killer, it’s nice to see you again.

[Frostwolf103]

Every time I see M- T, I think of Mr. T

[Prophylaxis]

I will be back closer to EoD.

@Silviu200530 do you have a completed wolfgame I can look at?