Mafia: Trials and Tribulations [Thread 1 - DO NOT POST]

well that is definitely a reach and a half, lol

Because I can think of multiple explanations for the posts you’re assigning significance to. Your reads therefore feel artificial.

Maria was talking to Apprentice I think.

Maria switched to voting Apprentice.

I mean u can literally decide, “I think that was my towniest post”, but that’s like your own self-bias, town you is of course trying to make good posts, and wolf you is trying to replicate that, or shade someone

but like to tell me, that Maria saying your posts feel artificial, comes across as, “Wanting to lunch me regardless of my alignment”, is just an unbelievable conclusion lmao

Can you explain some of these? Like I think there are plenty of reasons for millium to make that post as a wolf. I simply think that a wolf wouldn’t actually be in a mindset where they even think to make a post like that

it’s not a high level post or anything but I do think it’s one a wolf is unlikely to make

I didn’t say they wanted to lunch me I said they just wanted to bash me what?

I’m not exactly sure what the difference you’re describing here is. But to me, if someone made a gross error in reading me previously as wolf when I was a villager, I would quite easily mention it as a reason to discredit their read. I mean no reason not too right? And it works quite well at increasing doubt.

Speaking of questionable behaviour.

@lucky

Why did you only ask for my reasoning now rather than when I first cast my finger towards you?

1 Like

maybe im just built different, I dont tend to look at everyone pushing me as malice, but last game it was literally all wolves PoEing me lmao

and I still dont see how you concluded they want to policy you lol

I think they thought I was just purely insulting their play.

I do not think there will be much more productive discussion going down this front since it is likely they will feel defensive regardless of their alignment.

meh im having flashbacks of Marshal already
guess we will see

They didn’t attempt to do it in response to a scumread though (in which case I’d agree with you) and I think that a townie being preemptively upset at someone for not being able to read them correctly is much more likely than a wolf attempting to discredit italy’s slot. especially the way it was handled didn’t seem like an attempt to discredit

I guess what I’m trying to get at is I think a wolf posting in thread early and trying to fit in doesn’t just simply have that thought come to them with no prompting

:face_with_diagonal_mouth:

:thinking:

this is what I thought it clearly wasn’t. I thought they were just going to be belligerent and cooperative but they’ve been anything but so far so we’re all good

EBWOP *uncooperative

I think we might have froze Maria.
Good Job! @Apprentice

wat

Yes but you didn’t really pressure me no? I just voted you and then left, and then you never mentioned me again. I was just curious why.

Ok NM.