Mafia: Trials and Tribulations [Thread 1 - DO NOT POST]

they were in bastard mash and pokemash
anni last year too

Sorry for not remembering this Ici-with-the-cute-pfpf :frowning:

3 Likes

yeah! but those were big games and my playstyle means i tend to go under the radar in mashes, so

1 Like

See, Millium it s funny because we both play the game :crazy_face:

Will it be useful for us if we don’t myslynch a greenie?

I’ve caught up but I’d say that now my only main additions to what I’ve said is that:

Leafia overall has a lot of posts but a grand lack of content. Their posts are also filled with fallacies which prove that either Leafia truly doesn’t know how they come across to literally everyone else or that Leafia is trying to put something on this game. A lot of their interactions have been super back and forths which shows to me a lack of wishing to create individual content (E.G. Back and forth with Lucky concerning Maria/Lucky interactions). Leafia feels disingenuous to say the least, however, I cannot scumread them for that alone as Leafia feels like that often regardless of alignment.

Wisdom and Prophy have both been alright slots, not really creating a storm either way, but actually making content and being around for talking to people. I wouldn’t provide them a strong townread, but I’d say that they deserve a town lean for sure (6 or 7 on my usual scale)

Lucky honestly I’ve already went over, yall know what I think of them. I’m throwing Lucky and Leafia into a ‘Kill until at least one is dead’ pile atm. However, I still won’t be voting whichever one of them has most votes because of vanity stuff.

Millium and Maria are very likely just town. They’re my strongest reads so far and I think both are actively trying to keep things on track so that way we don’t fail to proceed due to unnecessary distractions. Their posts come across as genuine and helpful, I don’t actually see any sort of trickery behind them or agenda.

Marl’s alright, I think more townie than Prophy and Wisdom but less than Millium and Maria. I’m looking forward to seeing how our read on each other progresses because that’s always a fun part of us playing together but so far they’ve been 'aight.

expect further content this afternoon, i’m gonna go touch grass for a bit

1 Like

I think your arguments on Leafia are lovely but oh! If only you would also argument your other reads.

Wisdom and Prophy because they’re not stormy and because they know how to do arguments doesn’t mean it should be alignment indicative because these are players that can play along as either side.
Here you need to think how they’re doing their behavior than looking at what their behavior is, remember that everyone is a great actor as a villain in social deduction unless they’re under pressure, and everyone can look as a villain if they’re not under stress to comment.
That’s why Leafia is pushed but there’s still doubts, because Leafia could ve messed up at beginning so far, but can articulate a defense to manage to defend themselves.

Sorry, I don’t know what Seth did.

For Milly and M-T if they are wolves, I think there doesn’t have to be trickery because they can just simply let other townies do the myslynch for them, in case that happens, look carefully on what they are doing now and then what they’re doing at EoD.

Okay, for townies is more optimal to not panic as it can look worse.

Can’t sleep and you’re already acting like my execution is set into stone when it’s not. Sorry, but I doubt the villagers are that dumb.

Laughs i wish I had thought of doing that honestly.

It’s from judging each person individually without looking at anything else.

I have been solving and I’ve even been doing most of the solving here. Also, putting pressure on people makes iy harder for them to solve the gamestate.

Sorry about that though. Won’t happen again and I have no idea why you thought I was new and if you think I looked wolfy in that game, you should’ve seen my first game on the old site.

1 Like

You’re definitely tunneled if you’re town.

I do see what you’re getting at there, but I’m talking about in a vaccuum. You can’t just assume everyone is a illagerin these games. That’s a great way to lose.

Kiiru (Ryan) said that you posted but that they aren t concrete answers, what do you think about that?

Okay now beside going into the circle of “But I am doing my job!!” type of thinghie

Instigate TvT by defending Lucky a bit there? And stopping the misunderstanding by helping to clear it up? If I was a wolf and both of them were villagers, why would I help clear up the misunderstanding like that? Also, how are you so sure that Lucky and Maria are both villagers here?

Are you sure you’re reading this game here? What, I’m just supposed to ignore what goes on in the thread? I’ve also been putting out my own reads too if you haven’t noticed.

I’m not sure what to think of Kiiruma yet. I do think he’s vastly understating hiw much content I’ve been producing though, but I don’t know if it exactly comes from a wolfy mindset yet, but I will give him a scumlean for now. It also sounded like he has possible TMI that Maria/Seth are V/V with how he put one of his arguments. I don’t know what it means yet for his alignment, but I aim to find out.