Mafia: Trials and Tribulations [Thread 1 - DO NOT POST]

[Marluxion]

as wolf he just

[Marluxion]

does

[Marluxion]

this

[Marluxion]

and makes too much content for people to ever suspect him

[Marluxion]

the “can we really eliminate the 2000-poster???” strategy

[Silviu200530]

Eli sadly is always frozen.

I ve eliminated him in 2 games based on his inactivity and was a mistake

[Marluxion]

eliza

her

also
she can definitely make herself readable if she tries

[Marluxion]

as town at least

dont think i have literally ever seen her as w

[Kiiruma]

@Silviu200530

Wisdom and Prophy because they’re not stormy and because they know how to do arguments doesn’t mean it should be alignment indicative because these are players that can play along as either side.
Here you need to think how they’re doing their behavior than looking at what their behavior is, remember that everyone is a great actor as a villain in social deduction unless they’re under pressure, and everyone can look as a villain if they’re not under stress to comment.

Fair points and well made Silviu there. I know they’re both skilled players and that they’re certainly capable of such which you have mentioned, however, that shall become more apparent as time goes within this game, for now I’m able to make the base reads. And also it’s why Wisdom and Prophy are less towny than the others I’ve mentioned (Barring Leafia and Lucky)

@Silviu200530

For Milly and M-T if they are wolves, I think there doesn’t have to be trickery because they can just simply let other townies do the myslynch for them, in case that happens, look carefully on what they are doing now and then what they’re doing at EoD.

Of course, I mean we’ve already had some discussion of EoD plans, it’ll just be seeing who conforms to them and who attempts to mess with them more directly. Will someone prevent a tie/close tie thus screwing over Marl? Will I go back on my word and not be vanity-wagoning? I doubt Millium and Maria shall make mistakes that go against those but it’ll be good to see how any behaviour shifts as the day goes on.

@Leafia

I do see what you’re getting at there, but I’m talking about in a vaccuum. You can’t just assume everyone is a illagerin these games. That’s a great way to lose.

It’s why the use of “Rand wolf” or “Rand town” is useful. Because instead of saying percentages, you’re saying that based off the odds of the actual roll, what you think is realistic. Versus pulling figures out of nowhere.

@Leafia

Instigate TvT by defending Lucky a bit there? And stopping the misunderstanding by helping to clear it up? If I was a wolf and both of them were villagers, why would I help clear up the misunderstanding like that? Also, how are you so sure that Lucky and Maria are both villagers here?

TBH I don’t know if Lucky is town. I also have stated Lucky is on my (s)hit list this game and is in a murder group with you. I merely meant that hypothetically I can see this being W!You and T!Them easily due to how things progressed. It can just as easily be you sticking up for a wolf buddy tbh.

[Wisdom]

She put half of her time worrying about Litten, don’t think she’d do that to a wolf mate.

[Marluxion]

@Wisdom

She put half of her time worrying about Litten, don’t think she’d do that to a wolf mate.

that is… probably nai

[Marluxion]

her especially would hyperfocus on that kind of stuff regardless of either of their alignment

[Wisdom]

Regardless of her alignment I buy.
I still think it’s not w/w indicative though.
I’m not doing my chart this game so it doesn’t really matter ^^

[Silviu200530]

Sorry I didn’t know why she turned into Eliza so I kept calling her Eliza.

[Silviu200530]

*Eli

[Wisdom]

Silviu I recognize you, did we play in the w!Proph game?

[Silviu200530]

From a year ago?

[Silviu200530]

Sorry, I don’t remember you wait for my wisdom tooth to fall out.

[Wisdom]

Time is broken.
Maybe a year ago?
I subbed in for nightingale.
There was a lot of neighbors.

[Silviu200530]

A mash?