Mafia: Trials and Tribulations [Thread 1 - DO NOT POST]

Yeah, I really need to try and put myself in Wisdom’s shoes to figure out if there’s a plausible wolf motivation for her to immediately out the two people who targeted me last Night if her team tried to ninja-kill me and failed – as opposed to keeping that information to herself and kill Millium/Silviu over successive nights.

Maybe the rand should be Wisdom/Kiiruma?

I said I wanted the tie between me and Kiiruma.

How is that relevant.

Yeah that’s the main reason I’m not screaming for their death
at the same time, what the fuck wisdom

If I am confirmed then I’m effectively a confirmed vengeful, which is another good reason why I should be the tie today.

also wisdom is scum especially if a ninja exists, which they could take advantage of to incriminate some townies
i also don’t get why people just
assume they’re not lying and instead jump directly to a ninja

I’m notopposed to that even if Iwould prefer a tie between me and you.

ya I dig it

its actually pretty flimsy reasoning in hindsight

Because making the claim Wisdom made makes no sense if Wisdom is a wolf.

wait have you used your shot?

I’m fine with that too.

you were talking like you were going to use it tonight

I haven’t.

I’m going to use it tonight regardless of what happens.

1 Like

My goal with the rand is to give myself the highest chance to hit a wolf, as opposed to potentially randing between two townies

My issue is that like, if the wolves have any sort of roleblocker or way to interact with roles then the vengeful is neutered.

1 Like

Anyways since I’m effectively going to play like I’m a vengeful I’m sure I don’t need to describe the benefits of having a greenchecked vengeful, so I would prefer if the tie is on me.

Anyways, good night.

(Also if you use this logic to say I shouldn’t be the tie, don’t. I’m sure later in the game people will ignore that I wanted myself in the tie in which case we wasted a beneficial mechanical play for no reason.)

Isn’t it better that the wolves waste a roleblock on a slot they’re going to kill then a potentially valuable Townie?

Also I think the wolves are probably going to roleblock me even if you don’t put me in the tie so it’s a non issue.

And if I’m confirmed, I’m essentially a confirmed keep townie aliveizer. Which is why I’d prefer you and me be tied at EoD.

vengeful don’t need to be greenchecked
they are yeeted in lylo
that’s their role
that’s how they are confirmed
you don’t need to mech check them if you can yeet them with someone else

1 Like

We can debate the merits of having a greenchecked vengeful later.

What I want to have us focus on is who the remaining three wolves are.

it makes perfect sense, as I said, especially if a ninja exists

see that somebody claimed protective (I think this happened first?)
claim watcher > incriminate two townies > when they die, claim there was a ninja
either way they get two townies executed (probably), so

i suppose it is contingent upon either townies assuming that there is a ninja because default to truth or ninja flipping before