Mafia: Trials and Tribulations [Thread 1 - DO NOT POST]

That would be the main point of the theory

What’s a Miller?
Know it’s a meme and people talk about them on MU but I’m pretty sure they’ve never been a thing in the games I’ve played.

But I only softed before Millium claimed he doctored Proph. He didn’t know I was gonna claim watch

Miller → Redirector?

I dont know myself to be honest, a godfather would make sense to me if they can put names as they wish, but they have to visit you specifically

This does not make sense to frame silviu, mislead your result and attack Prophylaxis the same time, it has to be seen that real mafia attack is elsewhere that also failed.

That doesn’t make sense. Millium and Wisdom both were in better positions than Silviu, it’s not a plan to ML Silviu, it’s just the fact that we probably have a ninja.

Plus neither Godfathers or Millers would give false info to a Watcher, the only role which would is a Ninja.

That is not how a godfather works at all, wtf?

Because Silviu would have died that night, so that is why the scenario of Prophylaxis doesnt fit

But it does fit. Really easily.
Millium healed Prophy who was attacked by a NInja.
The healing ability proc’d before Silviu’s BG ability meaning Silviu didn’t have to die in Prophy’s place.

Ninja attacks players without being seen, correct.

I dont believe 100% on that scenario

Ok Frost, in what world does W!Millium or W!Wisdom take the trade to get Silviu out in a 1-for-1 when they’re already more townread than Silviu?

I dont believe Wisdom is scum in my scenario as they are the one that get fake resulted by the mafia they believe they saw Millium and Silviu visited Prophylaxis, to believe Silviu is the attacker

They have to pick Silviu specifically because they are aware what Silviu’s role is and set up to waste whole day to mislynch and make us confused on what happened, to lynch Millium or Prophy next?

Low-key that Millium is the one got fake resulted as they find out prophy is attacked but it wasnt the case, that is plausible as hidden mechanic to fool everyone with results, again low-key.

There is possibility that Prophy wasnt attacked at all, therefore the attack was elsewhere and failed by prevention or roleblocked (later would indicate Lucky) or whoever was jailkeeped that was suppose to be attacked.

Prophy’s attack that millium claimed has to be ruse

The fooling people with results, both examples are ones which would fool an alignment checker.
I don’t believe we’d have one which would give false feedback to a role like Millium’s.

Furthermore, Millium was vanillized as a result of their role. So that means Prophy was attacked. If it was just false results, I doubt that the hosts would vanillize Millium to play along with it, no, Millium being vanilla now is mechanical proof that Prophy WAS attacked.

As for Leafia, there is no way that Leafia gets executed, the only way for them to die is NK by mafia.

It is odd that they claimed that Silviu will turn out to be mislynch, but I am sure its too late to mislynch Leafia now.

It could fool a watcher though, theoretically

The role which could fool a watcher is called a Ninja.
Which I have said, countless times today.
And it is fairly assured we have one.

IDK how you came to this conclusion but Leaf is high on my priority of exe’ing.

Frost you’ve been insanely illogical throughout today which makes me think that you’re just trying to get derpcleared way too hard. Furthermore, that seems like TMI to say the least. ‘It’s too late to ML Leafia’, excuse me… wtf?

To support that, Mafia has to know either Silviu and Millum’s roles

No they don’t have to.
All they need to do is use a ninja to attack last night.
Which isn’t hard to do, they submit an action.

And I said I dont believe that, there is no way the attack is hidden but instead mislead the watcher that Prophy was attacked in the first place.

Silviu getting mislynched support that notion.