Mafia: Trials and Tribulations [Thread 1 - DO NOT POST]

I targeted Proph because he felt like a likely wolf target, not necessarily the factional kill but at least some kind of target.

Maybe it was hubris from last game but I was sure I had useful results when I watched not only one but TWO people.

And like, what roles would exists for three townies to target the same player? Like, I doubt any investigative (except watcher) or any killing role would have target him.

1 Like

unfortunately thereā€™s a small problem with this and thatā€™s the fact that iā€™m actually infinite guiltless strongman vig

1 Like

PROTECTIVES
NEIGBORIZER
INFINITE ANOUNT OF ROLES THAT COULD TARGET THEM
how long have you held the belief that multiple town canā€™t tsrget the same guy

Itā€™s also really weird you keep saying THREE TOWNIES
your role means nothing as to their alignments for visiting proph!

Why did you not assume that at least one of them could be protective and just
Immediatrly out them

You just said yourself that hes a likely wolf target

I feel like visits to a very strong and very villagery villager are very likely to be some support/protective

2 Likes

And why would I claim watcher if wolf? What if town watcher counterclaimed? Like, thereā€™s no way there are two town watchers, and w!me would know that. Iā€™d never do that gambit lol

"But maybe wolves had knowledge of there not being any watchers so it would be safe to fake claim "?

Yeah but also no itā€™s obvious Iā€™m the watcher.

how good is wisdom at mechanical stuff
like do you expect them as a villager to know better here?

wolf watchers exist

1 Like

You could be

:drum:

A wolf watcher

1 Like

never thought of that Chloe

1 Like

I didnā€™t plan to out anyone. I tried to fish for information. Millium claimed unpromted.

1 Like

If you really thought a wolf role might have targeted them
Why didnā€™t you ask for their roles or stuff before claiming a red

Iā€™d hope theyā€™d know better here!

Like idk how good they are with mech exactly but they are a very very experienced player and im concerned how the idea that town support roles (like theyre claiming to be!) would visit proph

1 Like

how did you plan to get info from them by claiming a red
thatā€™s like asking them to claim their roles in order to defend themselves

1 Like

you PEOPLE
donā€™t vote maria

EBWOP

1 Like

Like
Letā€™s look at what you did
You wanted to know why they visited, cuz you thought a wolf might have targeted them
So you claimed a red on them

I wanted to know where Italy visited marl
So I asked them, cuz thatā€™s the info I wanted

why didnā€™t you do what I did

1 Like

Claim a green on them then

Answer my earlier question

Do you have strong mechanical reasoning for maria to be town
not their claim

1 Like

If*

absolutely not
if theyā€™re mafia, even better!