Mafia: Trials and Tribulations [Thread 1 - DO NOT POST]

[Italy]

however it is important to consider that in both this game and their wolfgame they opened with engineer gaming while in scp fm they only opened with the word gaming

[Wisdom]

Kiiruma sounds the towniest of these. Leafia claims selfresolving, Marl seems provable if we ever get in a situation where we wagon him, which I think is dumb but weh. Lucky kinda pings me because it’s vague and easy to get away with faking.

[Wisdom]

Give me your PoE and I’ll sheep it!

(edit: obligatory exclamation mark)

[Silviu200530]

Kill Eli

[Silviu200530]

za…

[Prophylaxis]

@Prophylaxis

Okay, I’ve read up.

I have to peace out for work related reasons soon, but how I feel about today is: I have my behavioral towncore and people I feel uncomfortable wagonning today for various other reasons. As long as we tie two people in the PoE and get off Marl’s ability, I don’t particularly care who we execute D1.

Town
Prophylaxis

Behaviorally Town
Icibalus
Apprentice
Millium

Locked Into Claims
Marluxion
Leafia
Lucky

Don’t Want to Focus On D1
Silviu200530
Wisdom
Maria-Theresa
Kiiruma (?)
ElizaThePsycho (?)

PoE
Frostwolf103
Babel
Litten
Italy
Atlas

.

[Wisdom]

What makes Icibalus town?

I agree with this from what I’ve read. I still town read Atlas though but I noticed they posted like 100 more posts since I read them last so I probably should re-read them if they actually get spotlighted.

[Prophylaxis]

Looking forward postgame to check out that readslist and find out that like, everyone who I listed either as town or don’t want to focus on is actually a wolf.

[Prophylaxis]

@Wisdom

What makes Icibalus town?

I agree with this from what I’ve read. I still town read Atlas though but I noticed they posted like 100 more posts since I read them last so I probably should re-read them if they actually get spotlighted.

She’s my strongest townread atm.

|
v

@Prophylaxis

@Icibalus

wait hang on asecond i just thought through my leafia experience and i think i might have figured out leafia’s meta tell? let me check the games proph cited earlier, because i think i may have noticed a pattern

@Icibalus

oh my fucking goodness i think this might be right? if leafia’s tell is actually this god damn basic i’d be shocked

@Icibalus

yeah i think that might be it- leafia always has a self-centered gamestate but as wolf they possess more theory of mind about it

@Icibalus

this read probably begs explanation but it’s really finnicky and vibe-based so i’d prefer not to- the broad strokes of it is that leafia’s worldbuilding is intensely self-centered, and i do not mean this in a bad way, just an observation of how she plays. as wolf, though, she has her partners to look after as well as her, so leafia’s wolftell is that she demonstrates knowledge that the world does not revolve around her more

This chain of epiphany posts from Icibalus has only solidified my townread on her, btw. Think she’s my strongest townread at the moment, followed by Apprentice/Wisp?

[Silviu200530]

My face when I sheep a mafia and then they kill me in the end (Wind)

[Silviu200530]

I phrased this horribly, but you get the point

[Wisdom]

I thought she might be white-knighting Leafia but yeah I see what you mean! I generally read effort d1 as towny

[Silviu200530]

Why did you assume Icibalus was “white-knighting” (defending somebody senselessly) Leafia?

[Litten]

I don’t get how the claim is provable but I get why people want to allow marl to live for a day to use it

I just think it’s going to end up being a “if wagons are tied you get a vigilante shot” thing instead because it makes way more sense to punish town for randomizing it then to reward town for randomizing it

[Italy]

i have not claimed yet

[Prophylaxis]

@Wisdom

I thought she might be white-knighting Leafia but yeah I see what you mean! I generally read effort d1 as towny

Yeah - I feel like this D1 is mostly a crapshoot given again, a quarter to half of the playerbase is not very interested in hunting the wolves.

Just have no choice but to townread the people who are tryharding and try to sort the wolves in them later on :shrug:

[Litten]

tie me and marl
that way when marl dies I’m clear

I have god tier luck so there’s no way he accepts this if he’s a w

[Litten]

this may or may not be a joke

[Prophylaxis]

@Italy, if you’re town, then who are the wolves on your wagon?

Who is purposefully avoiding your wagon to not get the backlash for it when you flip?

who r the bad guys

[Italy]

what’s the vc