If we had no one else I’d say that’s a good idea but today I think there are other kills that are more pertinent
Such as? I’m honestly not sure where you stand right now. Do you still want Eliza dead?
Elaborate on why you think NP might be town.
For clarity, that post didn’t really explain anything to me because I don’t understand the thought process there.
And I’ve yet to see an NP post I actually liked. The ISO just feels particularly whatever. I’d appreciate some extra thoughts there because I don’t want to confbias myself into a bad read.
Ashlyn has also essentially done nothing, but:
- I kinda understand (she’s just been MLed on day 1 twice, I’d assume she wouldn’t want to make waves and polarizing statements early on regardless of what she actually believes).
- I expect her to start playing and giving reads closer to EoD, and they should hopefully make her alignment obvious. Every time I’ve seen her be misyeeted, she was obvtowning at EoD.
Eevee is obviously a complete shrugkill, I’d prefer to avoid that unless I really can’t find wolves anywhere else. I’ve actually been in a game where I townread so many people I advocated voting out a 2-poster on day 1, and while it didn’t go through, they were indeed mafia. That’s not what I’m feeling here; I have a couple of townreads I feel okay about and not much beyond that. NP stands out the most as someone who posted a fair bit without much substance to it in my opinion, but again, I’d like some outside input on that.
Eliza feels like a coinflip, as usual to me. I genuinely have no clue how to read her. What she did here seems like a complete mess on her part and I could interpret it both ways (just like I think Arctic described it?).
I’m completely blanking on Caspore and Flygon. Dum is realistically NAI but I kinda want to townread the postcap-related obstinacy for bad reasons. My townreads on Squirrel and Shending also feel like they’re for bad reasons but at least I had reasons.
Guava’s probably my strongest townread rn and I hope Arctic is town.
Assuming for the moment NP actually interpreted “from my point of view” as “im town” (which is so wtf ill grant it regardless of alignmemt), i think the way they wanted to check if thats what i meant was indeed townie, because a wolf coming in going “how are we doing my fellow townies” style isint exactly unusual
yeah thats weak, but ill be the first to admit that tbh
If I just sort the people on whom I had any V pings at all into one pile and everyone else into the other, this is what I get as my PoE:
Ashlyn (expecting her to play closer to EoD.)
Caspore
eevee (0-poster.)
Eliza (In her case, it’s just that I’m getting pinged both ways so strongly it results in a coinflip.)
Flygon
NinjaPenguin
Idk how I should feel about this. Forgot to talk about Kanave, I think she’s been decently towny by her standards? Like I said earlier, there’s a lack of the behavior I saw from her when I pushed her correctly (I’d like to pretend Pathological didn’t happen, but I can’t).
If I remove Ashlyn because I don’t particularly want to d1 her despite meming about it (and I don’t think she’s really been wolfy), remove eevee because his slot is =rand and that means 75% town, and remove Eliza because maybe she should also be =rand:
Caspore/Flygon/NinjaPenguin
I’d honestly be happy if this had at least one wolf, I don’t feel great about this at all. Mainly because I have no specific thoughts on two of these three players.
I don’t think it’s weak because I don’t understand, lmao.
Could be said about most of this game, really. I feel like I’m trudging through mud.
Can you simplify your point somehow?
like, NP had a interaction with me where they asked me why i used some specific wording, which they interpreted as me saying something among the lines of “hi i think this this and that because im villager”. Now his interpretation of my wording was completly wtf and not at all right, but him hunting for that feels like it could be town
im doing my best, its kinda difficult to because it specifically depends on two posts from a while back
To reiterate, I currently feel that Flygon is acting more wolf like than Eliza after closer inspection of Flygon’s posts about Eliza. She could still be a wolf so I would like one of them to die today but I’m leaning towards Flygon.
lmao
actually i think planning ahead is wolf indicative for eliza
i know i had TMI as the host but in helluva boss one post that really stuck out to me was eliza saying who she would flip next if the person she was pushing flipped town, unpromptedly, which i’ve like… never seen her do as town before
was this post
what does this mean
it was saying that i didn’t wolfread them but their posts were mostly easy/fakeable, and i still think this but i did bring up a couple of her posts which i thought were slightly towny
hey s- i mean flygon, you’re kinda doing that thing again where you start making worldviews based on who agrees/doesn’t agree with you and you should probably not do that
Literally I don’t remember what I was thinking when I said that I’m gonna be 100 with you. I think I thought they were the same alignment at the time? If I’m reading my own message correctlu? Which I don’t think rn.
WAIT I THINK I REMEMBER
Okay so I was saying that at the time I thought Flygon looked town, and that if Eliza was wolf I didn’t think the other wolves were going to vote with her on Flygon. She still voted Flygon and because of this I was considering the possibility that they were both town.
But now I just think Flygon is a wolf LOL.
hm
i kinda thought that she’s not really playing like someone who’s been ML’ed the past 3 games and wants to avoid that happening again, given she was mostly shrugkilled for lowposting and not giving out much content at all, and she’s kinda doing the same thing here. i can’t say she’s a wolf for not trying to do something different but the longer the games goes on before i see anything i townread from her the more concerned i’m getting
this is kinda questionable logic given it was early in the game plus i don’t know why you think wolves wouldn’t be willing to vote a town flygon
I was tunnelling Eliza and I was like “if Flygon is voting with me and people are calling me town they probably think Flygon is town too” which is stupid but that was the thought process
i’m glad we agree the thought process was stupid
does anybody have thoughts on squirrel
i don’t really agree with vulgard townreading them for the… confusion around eliza