I’m just a time traveler, don’t worry about it.
1 Like
I’ll be sure to silence you first.
3 Likes
The red check being on the new player is precisely why its a good idea. This would NEVER work on someone who had more experience
1 Like
I disagree they’ll react the same way either way. They might slip up on the way to their defense maybe but even a brand new player knows not to admit they’re on the evil team or to hint to it in any way. They’re not stupid.
If they’re town they know you are lying because they know what they are and as far as they’re concerned you cannot be telling the truth.
If they’re mafia, they’re still going to be pushing the narrative Magnus is lying instead of dropping hints like “hi I’m mafia investigator I know you’re lying haha”
what are you possibly hoping to achieve by doing this to a new player as opposed to someone who might react with an actual discernable reaction
Maybe I could give this as pass if Magnus did not then proceed to argue why anything prisma said to defend themselves was a “scummy” way to do things. Maybe you’re applying pressure but maybe you just think town is going to follow you and believe you. Maybe I should point this out so you don’t get away with it.
Yes i agree its not foolproof, but something like this only ever makes sense on an new player. There is 0 reason to expect a player with experience to not be able to react to a unexpected role claim, while someone thats starting might just get frozen
To be clear, I’m not saying my time zone is the one true reality, I’m saying that the fact that there was and never will be no Wednesday this week is the one true reality.
1 Like
There’s 0 reason to fake a redcheck on the most vulnerable player D1 and then proceed to call any defense they can muster scummy
If I’m scummy, that means you think May’s good, right? But that’s impossible.
doing it to a new town player will cause them to try anything to make themself less suspicious
doing it to a new mafia player does the same
the only thing is both end results make them look scummy
1 Like
I dissagree. + i didint feel like magnus was actively calling prism scummy, at least not immdeatly. They kinda walked into it themselves.
no
So you think magnus is mafia? Go ahead and vote
i have
this is after. They had a opening interaction where magnus was kinda just leading and seeing where it would go
but tbh i retract my read, i didin’t realize prisma actually snapvoted magnus instantly after the claim
UNVOTE
why does that mean you wont vote me?
Because my entire reason for suspecting you is i tought you froze and tried to find a way this situation works with both you and magnus being town (which a new mafia might do, since you would know magnus has to be town) but this can’t be the case if you instantly voted him anyways. Thats the natural reaction i would expect from someone who came into the thread on a relatively unfamiliar game and got instantly pushed
Votecount as of post #642
Neon (2): Lemonfairy, Silviu200530
Silviu200530 (2): Neon, crazynuto
Magnus (2): Prisma101, Jarek
Lemonfairy (1): ElizaThePsycho
Prisma101 (1): Magnus
Not Voting (6): Frostwolf103, BradLand, Gorta, Marluna, May, Dum
I think we did a pretty good job so far.