Nightmare Woods FM - MOD-ERROR: TOWN VICTORY

[Marluna]

From what I saw, in his case, I believe the last 1-2 hours of EoD should be more important, than the final VC, imho.

[Dum]

This. Last moments of D1 were absolute chaos voting wise, loads of CFDs happened.

[crazynuto]

lol that’s a good point

[Silviu200530]

It was also the case if we should either go for them or Eliza.

[Whysper]

@Neon

Which makes Dums EoD look really good in a vacuum and Dum look really town

Eliza can go either way but i think Elizas behavior is wolf and i think if Eliza is wolf Dum is also wolf. But if Eliza is not wolf Dum is not wolf.

Hmmm, I don’t really follow how if Eliza is wolf then that makes Dum wolf also. I thought you were saying that Gorta was bussed? Wouldn’t Eliza just have simply voted Gorta for that? Or are you now switched to thinking that it was Eliza trying to tie the whole time and save both?

[Silviu200530]

WHYSPERRAEREAR

[Whysper]

@Neon

Oh btw my ability means i did have everything under control at all times because I basically had a fail safe to prevent a tie.

Ohh, this explains your behavior a bit better if this is true. That you had an ability to break a tie.

[Whysper]

@Neon

This is pointless though and I’m becoming a bitch so let’s focus on the game.

The one where Eliza did the things she was blaming me for and repeatedly tried to save Dum.

And was willing to vote Gorta for bad reasons.

I think Eliza is the busser not you and i think Eliza is woof not you.

Wait, so you do think Eliza was bussing. But I still feel that is contradictory to thinking Eliza would do that by tying the votes instead of just putting her vote directly on Gorta. The only reason for trying to tie would be to save both Gorta and Dum.

[Whysper]

Haha, so I guess Neon and BradLand have established that they probably aren’t w/w

[Whysper]

@Neon

I really really hope you are a wolf and you don’t think this is somehow a good way to defend yourself.

Okay, this particular comment pings me a bit as w/w. Though I probably still think the rest of their interactions wouldn’t be w/w. They do seem to have a lot of history together.

[Whysper]

@Neon

I always like flipping the CW so Dum is still acceptable

Flipping the CW even when the one executed was mafia? And someone you think was bussed?

[Whysper]

@Prisma101

Killing someone I suspect would be the dumbest thing on earth to do

@Prisma101

Ok but if i kill someone who I suspected and they suspected me then that would just make me look more suspicious

Well, not if you are a town vig, then that’s exactly who you should target

[Silviu200530]

I don’t know, it looks like idle banter

[Whysper]

@Prisma101

Ok?… if they are town why are they killing town?

Well, if they are town, they are uninformed, so they don’t know for sure who is town and who isn’t. So they have to make guesses based on who they find suspicious.

[Whysper]

@Silviu200530

I don’t know, it looks like idle banter

Well, I wouldn’t exactly call it idle banter. It sounds like they have history together as wolves. And possibly a number of games together in general. And differences of opinion in how to play FM.

[Silviu200530]

Whyspah as you have experience in FM, what do you think is the best way to find scum? As we have an exceptionally low quantity of posts than usual? (A vulgard dream from heaven)

[Whysper]

@Jarek

Like you say that wolves would absolutely bus that, and sure I can see that but I can also see certain wolves being scared to lose a partner so early regardless of any ability because losing them early when town has the hardest time finding a wolf in the first place isn’t great. You can’t really say you deduced Gorta or anything or had a scumread on them as a wolf because a wolf wouldn’t have had time to set it up yet.

Yeah, I’ve been trying to think through the whole bus theory. At first it did make sense based on Gorta’s role. But then I got to thinking that if wolves were going to bus, wouldn’t they also try to get more out of it by being firmly on Gorta’s wagon and having a more certain scumread on him?

Like I think it was Brad who started the wagon, and he did it basically as a punt, which doesn’t seem like a good way to try to get credit. The only person who seems to be trying to get credit for the Gorta execution is Neon, but they are too firmly trying to say it was a bus.

[Whysper]

@Dum

Also, i am betting gorta’s role was not originally his, since it is decsinged to be Changed into the D1 Flip

Oh yes, good point. I guess that works in with the bus theory more, since he might have had a more powerful role that the wolves swapped with someone more capable of getting through to the end.

Though I’m still thinking that if a bus was the plan, they would have done more to get credit somehow.

[Whysper]

@crazynuto

Oh jeez, I thought it was starting today. I’m a bit confused at how two deaths could be possible. Maf is only allowed to kill once per night right? So was there like a vigilante that just didn’t claim or something?

Yeah, usually they only have a single factional kill. But it’s possible to have other abilities. Maybe like a 1-shot kill also I guess. Though I kind of agree with Jarek that they would more likely hold that for later. Especially maybe wait for more claims?

[Whysper]

@Silviu200530

Silviu…
Jarek top town
Neon town
Dum lean town

Rest is null.

What about Brad? He is just null for you?