If I had to choose I think Eliza has higher chance flipping red, and probably shading Hermes being their teammate. (or it is their actual teammate… It’s still a coinflip after either of them flipping red.)
So
/vote ElizaThePsycho
They are town reading a NAI post.
They are saying it put them in a “wolfy” position.
I don’t see them in that? Tbh it put them in a position that allowed more conversation to be made based off of that NAI post.
Also as I think Marluna is saying, how the read was formed was strange.
Ok so I’m gonna make a read and I know this is a reach but I don’t think Marluna is wolves with Hermes nor Eliza like ever.
So if Eliza flips Red here I’m clearing Marluna.
| Player | Votes | Voted By |
|---|---|---|
| Lucky | 2/5 | Hermes, ElizaThePsycho |
| ElizaThePsycho | 2/5 | Lucky, Marluna |
| Aleph | 1/5 | BradLand |
| Not Voting | 4 | Aleph, Gorta, Litten, clonedcheese |
REMINDER:
Just got hit with it.
Since mafia is forced to attack at night, shouldn’t we just go with noElims until Tracker finds a scum or get killed by mafia?
This way we won’t lynch the Tracker (the only reliable source in this game) and mafia has harder time to kill it.
We should just steal pike-chu.
pike pike pike pike
No not a great idea.
1)Tracker only has a real good accuracy if there is only 1 mafia left and if we did it this way mafia could just rotate kills.
2)By the time Tracker dies it could become MYLO/LYLO and we just screwed ourselves.
I’m currently thinking that Eliza is town, since their position on me doesn’t make sense regardless of Lucky’s alignment if they’re town or mafia since if lucky is town, then they’re drawing a massive amount of heat towards themselves for little to no reason. While if Lucky is Mafia it just results in both of them facing the maximum amount of pressure possible, which in this setup seems like a mistake.
To me it makes far more sense that a wolf would simply leave me and Lucky alone, rather than try to get into our fight directly.
I think this statement only true for inexperienced wolfs.
I saw experienced wolfes to blend in to arguments more often than not.
Dude what is this?
I’m sorry but if I’m reading this correctly your basically saying you town read them for something NAI and you don’t think wolves do NAI things.
Why are all your arguments like this.
They are like bad.
But wouldn’t it just be easier to just play both sides as it were?
I think a good wolf is likely going to recognize it makes more sense to not aggro one side too much, especially Lucky if he’s a villager.
What?
Wouldn’t that just aggro way more attention to themself?
Especially when we are talking about Seth…
I mean.
Situation 1 - TvT - Wolves CAN get involved with us because nothing really stops them from doing so. They pick a side then after one flips town they try and make the other one look worse and a good PoE choice, sure scum don’t HAVE to at all but some will.
Situation 2 - WvT - I could see you being a wolf here and Eli coming in as your partner to try and lower the chance of you being the execution and briefly defending you. In this setup wolves usually prefer to not lose their scum buddy Day 1.
Why would they aggro you instead of me if they’re a wolf?
I’m obviously much more reasonable than you are.
I’m not sure what you mean, can you explain?
Also your arguments to town read people this game have been:
They did something NAI. I don’t think scum risk NAI therefore they are town.
That’s like a lazy fake read that’s common for a wolf to do.